Editorial illustration.
Editorial illustration.
In Depth · United States · Rutgers–New Brunswick (New Jersey), UC Riverside (California)

What the Encampment Agreements Promised: A Clause-by-Clause Audit of Rutgers and UC Riverside

In the first week of May 2024, two public universities ended encampments with written agreements. Both refused to cut academic ties with Israel, and both promised reviews, committees and support for Palestinian students. The documents are short and specific, which makes them checkable. Most of the checking has not yet been done.

Summary

  • Rutgers–New Brunswick’s agreement ended the Voorhees Mall encampment by 4 p.m. on May 2, 2024. In it, the university states that “Rutgers will not terminate its partnership with Tel Aviv University” and promises support for “10 displaced Palestinian students,” a cultural center, a feasibility study for a Middle East studies department and a meeting on divestment.
  • UC Riverside’s amended agreement of May 3, 2024 committed the campus to post UC investment information, form an endowment task force and review Sabra hummus. It also confirmed that the School of Business had discontinued study-abroad programs in nine places, Israel among them.
  • UC Riverside’s FAQ says the business-school programs were dropped because they “were not offered under the auspices of the UC Riverside Office of International Affairs, nor are they consistent with university policies.”
  • On August 19, 2024, UC president Michael V. Drake told all chancellors to adopt systemwide rules barring encampments “unless specifically pre-approved,” unauthorized structures, blocking movement, and masking “for the purpose of evading or escaping discovery” while violating law or policy.
  • No public follow-up report from either campus on implementing these clauses was found for this piece. That gap is the story, and the template below is designed to close it.

Rutgers: ten clauses and a carve-out

The Rutgers–New Brunswick agreement is a single page. Its preamble says protesters “will leave the encampment, remove all tents and personal belongings, and clear the mall of all trash” by 4 p.m. on Thursday, May 2, and that the deal is “contingent upon no further disruptions and adherence to University policies.”

The ten numbered clauses fall into three groups.

What Rutgers refused. Clause 2 is unambiguous: “Rutgers will not terminate its partnership with Tel Aviv University. Agreements with global partners are a matter of scholarly inquiry.” On investments, the university offered process, not outcome. Clause 1 commits the president and the chair of the Joint Committee on Investments to “meet with no more than five student representatives to discuss the divestment request.”

What Rutgers promised to build. Support “for 10 displaced Palestinian students to finish their education at Rutgers” (clause 3). A plan for “a new cultural center with designated physical space and a hiring plan” by fall 2024 (clause 4). A revived relationship with Birzeit University, “established in 2022,” to explore research and student exchange (clause 5). Training “on anti-Palestinian, anti-Arab, and anti-Muslim racism for all RU administrators & staff” and a senior administrator hire (clause 7). A working group on “the creation of a Department of Middle East Studies” (clause 8).

What Rutgers kept. Clause 10 bars retaliation against employees for encampment involvement. The text then states that individual students “remain subject to the procedures of the Code of Student Conduct,” with ending the encampment treated as “a favorable mitigating factor.” It also excludes conduct “that occur[s] or come[s] to be known after this agreement.”

The context matters for weighing these terms. NJ Spotlight News reported that in the student assembly’s April election, more than 80% of voting Rutgers–New Brunswick students backed divestment and 78% backed ending the Tel Aviv relationship, but only “about 8,000 of the school’s nearly 37,000 undergraduate students participated.” The university told the outlet there were more than 7,000 Arab, Muslim and Palestinian students on campus.

UC Riverside: investments, hummus and business-school trips

The UC Riverside deal came a day later. Chancellor Kim A. Wilcox announced that the encampment would end “no later than midnight tonight” and wrote that the agreement “does not change the realities of the war in Gaza, or the need to address antisemitism, Islamophobia, and other forms of bias and discrimination.”

The Riverside Record summarized the main terms. The campus agreed to post “all publicly available information” about UC investments. It agreed to “form a task force by the end of the Spring 2024 quarter to explore the removal of UCR’s endowment from the management of the UC Investment’s Office,” with attention to “companies involved in arms manufacturing and delivery.” There would be bimonthly meetings with Auxiliary Services and “an ongoing review of Sabra Hummus,” which the paper noted is a PepsiCo–Strauss Group joint venture.

The clause that drew national attention was the last. The agreement said the School of Business “has discontinued its global programs in Oxford, the U.S., Cuba, Vietnam, Brazil, China, Egypt, Jordan and Israel.” The university’s FAQ gave the reason as a policy problem, not a political one. The programs “were not offered under the auspices of the UC Riverside Office of International Affairs, nor are they consistent with university policies. So they are being discontinued.” On Sabra, the FAQ said its “availability on campus will be reviewed in the same manner as other vendors.”

The system responds

UC’s systemwide answer arrived in August. Drake’s letter of August 19, 2024 told chancellors that campus policies “must clarify” a list of prohibitions:

  • “no person shall camp, set up or erect a campsite, or occupy a tent or other temporary housing structure on University property, unless specifically pre-approved”;
  • no “unauthorized structures”;
  • no blocking “the movement of another person”;
  • no wearing of “a mask or personal disguise” to intimidate or “for the purpose of evading or escaping discovery, recognition, or identification in the commission of violations of law or policy”;
  • no refusal “to identify themselves while on University property to University officials.”

The directive did not undo the Riverside agreement. It made a repeat of spring 2024 a clear policy violation on every UC campus.

What a follow-up should ask

ClauseInstitutionPromiseCheck against
1RutgersMeeting on divestmentJoint Committee on Investments minutes
3Rutgers10 displaced Palestinian studentsAdmissions or Rutgers Global records
4RutgersCultural center plan by fall 2024Student Affairs announcements
8RutgersMiddle East studies feasibility studyChancellor’s office reports
InvestmentsUC RiversidePost UC investment informationUCR website
EndowmentUC RiversideTask force on moving endowmentTask force report
SabraUC RiversideVendor reviewAuxiliary Services

Rutgers’s own Investment Policy Statement, published in January 2024, is the baseline document for any divestment question there; it sets out the role of the Joint Committee on Investments. Whether any policy changed after the promised meeting can be checked against later versions of that document.

Sources

  1. Rutgers University, Rutgers–New Brunswick encampment agreement, May 2024
  2. NJ Spotlight News, “How Rutgers student protest came to an agreed end,” May 2024
  3. Rutgers University, Investment Policy Statement, January 2024
  4. UC Riverside, “Agreement to peacefully end encampment on campus,” May 3, 2024
  5. UC Riverside, amended agreement, May 3, 2024. (PDF loads but did not yield extractable text; terms confirmed via sources 4, 6 and 7)
  6. UC Riverside, “FAQs on encampment agreement.”
  7. The Riverside Record, “Student Protesters, UCR Administration Reach Agreement To End Encampment,” May 2024
  8. Michael V. Drake, letter to chancellors on policies impacting expressive activity, August 19, 2024 (via CalMatters)
  9. University of California, “Directives on Policies Impacting Expressive Activities: FAQ.”

Further reading

Topics: encampment, research ties, legal outcome.