Editorial illustration.
Editorial illustration.
In Depth · United States · Immigration and campus speech

A Federal Judge Heard Nine Days of Evidence on the Student Deportation Campaign. Here Is What the Record Shows.

The trial court in AAUP v. Rubio found that two cabinet secretaries used immigration law to chill protected speech. The findings are detailed, the remedy is contested, and the case is now before the First Circuit.

Summary

  • After a nine-day bench trial with 15 witnesses and 250 exhibits, a federal judge in Boston found on September 30, 2025, by clear and convincing evidence, that Secretaries Kristi Noem and Marco Rubio and their subordinates had implemented two executive orders in a viewpoint-discriminatory way to chill protected speech.
  • Testimony showed that a Homeland Security Investigations “Tiger Team” was formed in March 2025 to review roughly 5,000 names, drawn mostly from the Canary Mission website. Reports were prepared on fewer than 5 percent of them.
  • The January 22, 2026 judgment declared the policy unconstitutional and vacated it under the Administrative Procedure Act. It also created a special “sanction” procedure for noncitizen members of the plaintiff groups.
  • On April 7, 2026 the First Circuit stayed the sanction alone, at the government’s request and without opposition. Briefing on both sides’ appeals closed on October 29, 2026.

The case

The plaintiffs are the American Association of University Professors, its Harvard, NYU and Rutgers chapters, and the Middle East Studies Association. They are represented by, among others, the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University. They sued in March 2025, after immigration authorities detained several noncitizen students and scholars who had been involved in pro-Palestinian advocacy.

They did not sue on behalf of any one detained person. Their claim was that the government had adopted a policy of using deportation and visa revocation against noncitizens for their political speech, and that this policy chilled the speech of their members.

Judge William G. Young of the District of Massachusetts held what he described as a full hearing and a nine-day bench trial. The court heard 15 witnesses and admitted 250 exhibits, including documents, photographs and video clips. His opinion of September 30, 2025 runs to 161 pages and is reported at 802 F. Supp. 3d 120.

How the names were gathered

The most specific findings concern how targets were identified. They rest largely on the testimony of an assistant director in HSI’s intelligence office, identified in the opinion as AD Hatch.

According to the opinion, Hatch was told by DHS leadership, whom he could not recall, to review the names of student protesters on the Canary Mission website. The site contains a database of more than 5,000 individuals. Before March 2025 he had not been aware of it. The court noted that it admitted the Canary Mission exhibit not for its truth but as evidence of what officials used as a primary source. It made no findings about the accuracy of the site’s portrayals.

Within about a week of an early March meeting, a “Tiger Team” was assembled to speed up the preparation of reports of analysis, known as ROAs. Analysts were pulled from the counterintelligence, counterterrorism, cyber and global trade intelligence units. Hatch testified that the normal unit “couldn’t handle that workload.” He said he was given no deadline, but taking six months to get through 5,000 names was not going to be acceptable.

The court found that Canary Mission’s list made up the bulk of the sources. The team also used the website of Betar U.S. for additional names and received lists from HSI “top leadership,” some of which apparently came from the office of the border czar, Tom Homan. Hatch had held his position since 2019 and had never been asked to review protest activity before 2025. Of the approximately 5,000 individuals reviewed, ROAs were prepared on fewer than 5 percent.

The opinion notes that “Tiger Team” is common internal shorthand for fast, intense work. In the court’s words, it is not pejorative and was not meant to intimidate or to become public.

What the reports said

The opinion quotes several ROAs. Two are central to the public cases that followed.

On March 6, 2025, HSI issued an ROA on Mahmoud Khalil, a lawful permanent resident married to a U.S. citizen. “No criminal history was noted in the report,” the court wrote. The report’s attachments, including a Canary Mission article, indicated that he had been critical of Israel and had taken part in demonstrations at Columbia.

On March 17, 2025, HSI issued an ROA on Rümeysa Öztürk, a Tufts graduate student on a student visa. HSI located no criminal history or investigations associated with her. It attached a February 2025 Canary Mission posting about her. After reviewing the record, the court found “no evidence that Öztürk did anything but co-author an op-ed” criticizing the university’s position on investments connected with Israel.

The opinion also discusses ROAs and actions involving other students and scholars, including Yunseo Chung and Badar Khan Suri.

What the court decided, and what it did not

The judgment of January 22, 2026 has three operative parts.

First, a declaration. The court quoted its earlier finding that Noem and Rubio “intentionally and in concert implemented Executive Orders 14161 and 14188 in a viewpoint-discriminatory way to chill protected speech.” It declared that the “enforcement policy” and its implementation violate the First Amendment and the Administrative Procedure Act. It found the policy arbitrary and capricious because it reversed prior policy without reasoned explanation and relied on statutes never used this way.

Second, vacatur. Under 5 U.S.C. § 706(2), the court declared the policy and its implementation void and set aside.

Third, a “sanction.” Any noncitizen who was a member of AAUP or MESA from March 25 through September 30, 2025 may bring a “sanction action” in federal court if their immigration status is changed from what it was on January 20, 2025. Once membership is shown, the change is presumed to be retaliation. It is void unless the government proves otherwise by clear and convincing evidence, and removal is paused while the action is pending. The court limited this relief to members, citing the Supreme Court’s 2025 CASA decision on the scope of remedies.

The court did not grant everything the plaintiffs sought. According to the government’s reply brief, Judge Young rejected the claim that officials’ public statements by themselves violated the First Amendment, and he declined to issue an injunction. The plaintiffs have cross-appealed on both points.

The appeal

The government appealed (No. 26-1141) and the plaintiffs cross-appealed (No. 26-1195). On April 7, 2026, a First Circuit panel of Judges Gelpí, Montecalvo and Rikelman granted the government’s unopposed motion to stay “the portion of the district court’s [annotated] judgment imposing the ‘Sanction.’” The declaration and vacatur were not stayed.

The government filed its opening brief on July 6, 2026, the plaintiffs filed on August 5, 2026, and the government replied on October 29, 2026. The reply’s central argument is jurisdictional. It says the case was “beyond the district court’s jurisdiction from the beginning,” citing provisions of the Immigration and Nationality Act that channel challenges to removal into immigration proceedings (8 U.S.C. § 1252(b)(9) and (g)), bar classwide injunctions against enforcement (§ 1252(f)(1)) and limit review of visa revocations (§ 1201(i)). On the merits, it says officials were exercising their own speech rights by announcing that valid immigration laws would be enforced.

What to watch

The First Circuit’s decision will determine whether federal district courts can hear a policy-level challenge of this kind at all, separate from individual removal cases. The individual cases mentioned in the opinion have their own dockets, and their status should be checked separately before any update. This report does not summarize them.

Sources

  1. Knight First Amendment Institute, case page, AAUP v. Rubio
  2. AAUP v. Rubio, No. 1:25-cv-10685-WGY (D. Mass.), findings of fact and conclusions of law, September 30, 2025 (Doc. 261)
  3. AAUP v. Rubio, annotated judgment, January 22, 2026 (Doc. 313)
  4. AAUP v. Rubio, Nos. 26-1141 and 26-1195 (1st Cir.), order of April 7, 2026
  5. Government’s reply brief, October 29, 2026, via the Knight Institute case page