
From a Senate Inquiry to a Statute: How France Rewrote University Discipline in Thirteen Months
Law 2025-732 adds reporting duties, an “equality and diversity” mission and regional disciplinary panels chaired by judges. The figures that drove it came from a Senate report, which was also candid about what those figures could not show.
Summary
- A Senate fact-finding report filed on June 26, 2024 documented a rise in antisemitic acts on French campuses after October 7, 2023 and made 11 recommendations. It also warned that centralized reporting had existed only since August 2023 and that key events were still disputed.
- The resulting bill was adopted by the Senate on February 20, 2025 and by the National Assembly on May 7, 2025. A joint committee text passed both houses by July 2, 2025, and the law was promulgated on July 31, 2025.
- The law requires anti-antisemitism and anti-racism training, creates an anonymous reporting system with a duty for staff to report, and lets university heads remove antisemitic or hateful displays. Each regional education authority gets a common disciplinary section chaired by a member of the administrative judiciary.
- Sixty-plus deputies challenged two disciplinary provisions. On July 29, 2025 the Conseil constitutionnel held both constitutional.
What the Senate found, and what it could not
The culture and education committee of the Senate set up a fact-finding mission on antisemitism in higher education. Its rapporteurs, Pierre-Antoine Levi and Bernard Fialaire, filed report no. 705 on June 26, 2024.
The report set national figures first. According to the intelligence service data it quoted, 1,676 antisemitic acts were recorded in France in 2023, compared with 436 in 2022. More than 1,200 of them came between October 7 and the end of 2023, and 366 more were recorded in the first quarter of 2024.
For universities, it assembled three partial sources. The Higher Education Ministry’s ad hoc data for October 9, 2023 to May 10, 2024 counted 184 reported facts. Of these, 154 were pro-Palestinian demonstrations “likely to cause disturbances.” The other 30 were 13 inscriptions, 7 insults, 6 threats, 3 cases of apology for terrorism and 1 act of physical violence. A France Universités survey of 82 university presidents found 67 antisemitic acts since October 7, compared with 33 in the whole of the 2022–23 academic year. The Justice Ministry’s criminal affairs directorate reported 399 cases handled by May 7, 2024 under its national anti-hate framework, across all settings, not only universities.
The rapporteurs were explicit about the limits. Centralized reporting of such incidents by universities began only in August 2023, so there was no reliable baseline. On the March 12, 2024 occupation of an amphitheater at Sciences Po, they wrote that the “exact sequence” of events “remains to be established.” They also described an assault in Strasbourg on the night of January 28–29, 2024.
Their 11 recommendations included using the IHRA working definition of antisemitism as a teaching tool (recommendation 4) and reforming discipline (recommendation 10).
The legislative path
The rapporteurs turned the recommendations into a bill, Senate proposal no. 26 (2024–2025). The government used the accelerated procedure, which allows one reading in each house before a joint committee. According to the official legislative record printed with the law:
- The Senate adopted the text on February 20, 2025, on the basis of committee report no. 335.
- The National Assembly debated it on May 6 and 7, 2025, and adopted it on May 7, with Constance Le Grip and Pierre Henriet as rapporteurs (report no. 1357).
- A joint committee agreed a text. The Senate adopted it on June 19, 2025 and the Assembly on July 2, 2025.
On July 7, 2025, more than 60 deputies, with Mathilde Panot listed first, referred the law to the Conseil constitutionnel.
What the law does
The law has four articles, and three of them carry its substance.
Training (Article 1). Higher education institutions must provide training on combating antisemitism, racism, discrimination, violence and hate. The same wording is added to the missions of teacher-training institutes and to the training given to student representatives.
Detection and reporting (Article 2). Each university must create an “equality and diversity” mission. It runs a reporting system for antisemitic, racist, discriminatory, violent or hateful acts that guarantees anonymity to victims and witnesses. Reports go to the university head and are compiled statistically.
Any staff member who learns of such an act connected with university life, on or off campus, must report it “without delay.” The university head must have antisemitic, racist, discriminatory or hate-inciting displays, inscriptions, emblems and installations removed as soon as possible where they are manifestly visible.
The government must give Parliament an annual quantitative and qualitative report on the reports received, what was done about them and the prevention measures taken. The same section applies to private non-profit institutions recognized as serving the public interest.
Discipline (Article 3). In each regional education authority, the rector creates a common disciplinary section for public universities, chaired by a member of the administrative judiciary. A university head can refer a student case to it instead of the university’s own section.
The law also lists, for the first time, the types of student misconduct. They are:
- breaches of the rules on university life or of internal regulations;
- fraud;
- violence or harassment;
- acts of antisemitism, racism, discrimination or incitement to hatred or violence;
- acts likely to disrupt the order or proper functioning of the institution.
Acts committed off campus can be punished when they have a “sufficient link” to the institution or its activities. For violence, harassment, antisemitism, racism, discrimination, incitement or disruption, the university head can bar a student from all or part of the premises until the proceedings end, with measures to keep the student’s studies going. Victims of violence, harassment or hate acts are told when proceedings begin, how they progress and how they end.
The constitutional challenge
The deputies challenged two parts of Article 3. They argued that Parliament had left too much to decree in setting up the regional sections. They also argued that the list of misconduct was too vague, reached off-campus conduct without a clear link to the institution, and breached the principles of legality, proportionality and non bis in idem.
The Conseil constitutionnel rejected both arguments on July 29, 2025 (decision 2025-890 DC). It held that the composition and operating rules of a disciplinary section are not matters reserved to statute. On the misconduct list, it found that the “sufficient link” requirement was not equivocal and was precise enough to protect against arbitrariness. It did not examine the law’s other provisions. The decision was published in the Journal officiel on August 1, 2025, alongside the promulgated law.
What remains to be measured
Much of the law depends on decrees. These include the rules for the regional sections, for informing victims and for the powers of investigation given to university heads. This audit found a reference to an implementing decree in early 2026 but could not verify it on Légifrance, and it should be confirmed before publication.
The annual report to Parliament, once published, will be the first national series built from university reporting systems rather than from ad hoc surveys. That is the gap the Senate report identified in 2024. Comparisons with the 2023–24 figures should be made with care, because the reporting duty itself will raise the number of recorded cases.
Sources
- Sénat, report no. 705 (2023–2024), Levi and Fialaire, June 26, 2024
- Sénat, fact-finding mission page
- Sénat, committee report no. 335 (2024–2025)
- Sénat, legislative file for proposal no. 26 (2024–2025)
- Assemblée nationale, report no. 1357, Le Grip and Henriet
- Loi n° 2025-732 du 31 juillet 2025, Légifrance
- Conseil constitutionnel, decision 2025-890 DC, July 29, 2025