
“From the River to the Sea” in German Courts: Which Bans Held and Which Fell
In Bremen and Düsseldorf, courts lifted bans on a map, on “child murderer Israel” and on denying Israel’s right to exist. The ban on the river slogan was upheld each time, without a final answer on whether it is a crime.
Summary
- In April 2024 a Bremen court lifted three restrictions on a small weekly rally, including the ban on “From the river to the sea”. The next day the appeal court reinstated the slogan ban and left the other two lifted.
- In October 2025 the same Bremen court lifted bans on “Zionists are fascists” and “All together against Zionism” but kept the river slogan banned.
- In November 2025 North Rhine-Westphalia’s higher administrative court ruled that denying Israel’s right to exist is not in itself a criminal offence, lifted that ban, and upheld bans on the river slogan and on “Yalla, yalla, Intifada”.
- The administrative courts did not decide whether the river slogan is a criminal Hamas emblem. A criminal appeal court in Düsseldorf upheld a conviction for it in November 2025.
Bremen, April 2024: one day, two rulings
Bremen’s public order office restricted a stationary rally of about 20 people, held on Thursdays from May to June 2024. On April 29, the 5th chamber of the Bremen administrative court lifted three of the restrictions: a ban on a map of Israel’s territory in the colours of the Palestinian flag, on “From the River to the sea. Palestine will be free.”, and on “Kindermörder Israel” (child murderer Israel). The chamber wrote that the slogan “ist zum derzeitigen Zeitpunkt anders zu bewerten als noch Ende Oktober 2023” (is to be assessed differently at this time than at the end of October 2023), and that denying Israel’s right to exist “ist für sich genommen keine strafbare Äußerung” (is not in itself a criminal statement).
The city appealed. On April 30, the Higher Administrative Court of Bremen reinstated the ban on the slogan. It found it “naheliegend, dass sich die Hamas die Parole zu eigen gemacht hat” (likely that Hamas has adopted the slogan as its own), left open whether using it is a crime, and decided on a weighing of consequences: the organiser could make her point without it, and a statement once made cannot be undone. The court kept the other two bans lifted, finding that “Kindermörder Israel” can be understood as protected, if exaggerated, criticism of the Gaza war. The order cannot be appealed.
Bremen, October 2025: “Zionists” is not automatically “Jews”
For a march on October 25, 2025, the city banned, among other things, “Zionisten sind Faschisten” and “Alle zusammen gegen Zionismus”. The Bremen administrative court lifted both. The word Zionist could be read as a code for Jews, it said, but a political reading as criticism of Israel’s government and conduct of the war could not be excluded: “Es stehen Deutungsvarianten zur Verfügung, die nicht den Tatbestand von § 130 Abs. 1 StGB erfüllen” (readings are available that do not meet the offence of incitement). It upheld the river slogan ban, noting that “eine höchstgerichtliche Klärung ist noch nicht erfolgt” (no highest court has yet settled the question).
Düsseldorf, November 2025: the right to exist
Düsseldorf police restricted a march with two conditions: a ban on denying Israel’s right to exist, and a list of banned slogans. On November 21, 2025, the 15th senate of the Higher Administrative Court of North Rhine-Westphalia lifted the first condition: “Das Existenzrecht des Staates Israel in Abrede zu stellen, obgleich dies als antizionistisch oder gar antisemitisch gewertet werden kann, verwirklicht für sich genommen grundsätzlich keinen Straftatbestand” (denying the existence of the State of Israel, although it may be regarded as anti-Zionist or even antisemitic, does not in itself constitute a criminal offence). The court added that it could become one with further circumstances, such as a call for violent elimination.
The court also lifted the ban on “There is only one state – Palestine 48” and rejected the argument that Germany’s commitment to Israel’s security, the Staatsräson, could justify restrictions: “Hierbei handelt es sich um eine politische Absichtsbekundung” (it is a statement of political intent). It upheld the ban on “Yalla, yalla, Intifada”, finding that in its historical context the chant very probably amounted to approving terrorist attacks, and upheld the river slogan ban on a weighing of consequences. The order is final.
The criminal courts
The administrative rulings decided only whether bans could stand before an assembly. Whether saying the slogan is a crime is for the criminal courts, and no ruling of the Federal Court of Justice was found. On November 25, 2025 the Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court (1 ORs 24/25) upheld a fine imposed on a protester who carried the slogan on a placard at a demonstration in November 2023, treating it as an emblem of Hamas; it left open whether later uses, further from October 7, might be judged differently.
What the rulings show together
Across the four decisions, courts lifted bans on images, insults directed at the state and anti-Zionist slogans when a lawful reading was possible, and kept bans on the river slogan and on “Intifada” chants. In every administrative case the slogan ban was upheld on a weighing of consequences, not on a finding that it is criminal. A ruling by the Federal Court of Justice would settle the question that all of these courts left open.
Sources
- Verwaltungsgericht Bremen, order of April 29, 2024, 5 V 1013/24
- Oberverwaltungsgericht Bremen, order of April 30, 2024, 1 B 163/24
- Verwaltungsgericht Bremen, order of October 24, 2025, 5 V 3679/25
- Oberverwaltungsgericht NRW, order of November 21, 2025, 15 B 1300/25
- Oberlandesgericht Düsseldorf, judgment of November 25, 2025, 1 ORs 24/25 (NRWE)
Every fact in this report is taken from the documents listed above. Updated November 19, 2026.