
Paralympics, a Football Match and the Terror Alert: Why Occitanie’s Courts Let the Bans Stand
In Montpellier and Toulouse, judges upheld bans on pro-Palestinian gatherings because the police were already committed elsewhere. The rulings name the competing events; none says what the deployments cost.
Summary
- The Montpellier administrative court upheld bans on demonstrations in Montpellier and Béziers on August 30 and 31, 2024, while police were also deployed for the Paralympic Games, a liberation anniversary and a football match.
- The same order records three arrests during the Olympic torch relay in May 2024 and two people held in custody after a twinning sign on a municipal building was painted over.
- In Toulouse in October 2023, the court upheld a ban because notice came too late to deploy police, already stretched by the national terror alert.
- No document gives the number of officers or the cost. The Interior Ministry attached the Montpellier order to a parliamentary answer without giving any figures.
Montpellier, August 2024
In orders 2405015 and 2405017 of August 30, 2024, the Montpellier administrative court refused to suspend the prefect’s bans on pro-Palestinian demonstrations in Montpellier and Béziers. Police in the Hérault were committed that weekend to the Paralympic Games, the 80th anniversary of the city’s liberation and a football match, and “il ne résulte pas de l’instruction que les forces de l’ordre de l’Hérault … soient totalement en mesure de prévenir d’éventuels heurts” (it does not follow from the case file that the Hérault police were fully able to prevent possible clashes).
The order also records earlier incidents: three arrests during the Olympic torch relay on May 13, 2024, and two people taken into custody after a twinning sign on a municipal building was painted over, following a complaint by the metropolitan authority. The Interior Ministry later attached the order to its answer to two written questions in the National Assembly, without giving any count of bans, proceedings or costs.
Toulouse, October 2023
On October 25, 2023, the Toulouse administrative court refused to suspend a ban on a gathering that day. Notice had been given less than three days in advance, which “compromet la possibilité de mobiliser en temps utile les forces de l’ordre” (compromises the possibility of mobilising police in time). At the hearing, the prefect said police were already “beaucoup sollicitées par le plan vigipirate” (heavily stretched by the Vigipirate terror alert plan), according to the court’s release.
What is not recorded
In both cases, the strain on the police is the reason for the ban, and neither the orders nor the ministry’s answer quantify it: no officer numbers, no hours, no cost.
Sources
- Tribunal administratif de Montpellier, orders 2405015 and 2405017, August 30, 2024
- Assemblée nationale, written questions 17-1125 and 17-1127, ministry answer of June 17, 2025
- Tribunal administratif de Toulouse, order 2306474, October 25, 2023
- Tribunal administratif de Toulouse, press release of October 26, 2023
Every fact in this report is taken from the documents listed above. Updated November 19, 2026.