Editorial illustration.
Editorial illustration.
France Desk · Transparency

France Bans Protests Because Its Police Are Stretched. It Does Not Count What That Costs.

Prefects across France have banned pro-Palestinian gatherings citing overstretched police. The Interior Ministry says it does not account for the cost of police operations, yet priced one gendarmerie operation at €380,000 when asked. Questions about the protests went unanswered.

Summary

  • From Marseille to Lille, Tours, Toulouse, Montpellier, Bordeaux and Nantes, ban orders cite the strain on the police. None gives a number of officers or a cost.
  • The Interior Ministry has told parliament it does not account for the cost of police operations, and that such a cost would be particularly complex to establish.
  • When asked about a single gendarmerie operation against farmers in the Ariège, the ministry put its extra cost at about €380,000.
  • Written questions about the campus protests were withdrawn unanswered when the Assembly was dissolved. No official count of banned demonstrations exists, nationally or by region.

The reason given, and the figure missing

In October 2023 and after, prefects banned pro-Palestinian gatherings across France on the ground that the police could not cope. In [Tours](fr-tours-not-enough-police.html), officers were too few at weekends. In [Lille](fr-lille-football-match-ban.html), all were at a football match. In [Marseille](fr-marseille-ban-order.html), reinforcements could not arrive in time. In [Montpellier and Toulouse](fr-occitanie-stretched-police.html), they were committed to the Paralympics and the terror alert. In [Le Havre](fr-le-havre-reinforcements.html), a ban was lifted when a gendarmerie squadron arrived. Not one of these orders gives a number of officers or a cost.

What the ministry told parliament

SubjectWhat the state saidDocument
Cost of police operationsThe Interior Ministry “does not account for the cost of police and gendarmerie operations”, adding such a cost “would be particularly complex to establish”.Written question 16-8045, answer of October 31, 2023 (on the pension protests)
Cost of one operation, when askedFor a gendarmerie operation against farmers in the Ariège, the ministry gave a figure: about €380,000 in extra cost.Written questions 17-11993 and 17-11994, answer of June 23, 2026
Crackdown on campus mobilisations for PalestineNo answer. The question was withdrawn when the Assembly was dissolved.Written question 16-18541, June 11, 2024
Violence and blockades at universities, including Grenoble and BordeauxNo answer. Withdrawn at the end of the term.Written question 16-17320, April 23, 2024
The blockade of Lyon 2’s Porte des Alpes campusNo answer in the published record.Written question 17-6263, April 29, 2025
Bans and proceedings in Montpellier and elsewhereThe ministry answered without any count of bans, proceedings or costs.Written questions 17-1125 and 17-1127, answer of June 17, 2025

No count of bans

There is no official national or regional count of declared or banned demonstrations. Each ban is published as a separate order in the gazette of one department. Where courts examined the bans, several found the state had not shown it lacked the means to keep order, in [Angoulême](fr-nouvelle-aquitaine-bans.html), [Besançon](fr-besancon-state-pays.html) and Metz.

Why it matters

Police time is paid for by taxpayers, and when it is short, the right to demonstrate is restricted. Without published figures on deployments and costs, the public cannot check either the bans or the spending. The Ariège answer shows the ministry can produce such a figure when asked about a specific operation. Researchez will add any figure the state publishes.

Sources

  1. Assemblée nationale, written question 16-8045, answer of October 31, 2023
  2. Assemblée nationale, written questions 17-11993 and 17-11994, answer of June 23, 2026
  3. Assemblée nationale, written question 16-18541
  4. Assemblée nationale, written question 16-17320
  5. Assemblée nationale, written question 17-6263
  6. Assemblée nationale, written questions 17-1125 and 17-1127

Every fact in this report is taken from the documents listed above. Updated November 19, 2026.