Editorial illustration.
Editorial illustration.
In Depth · Netherlands · University of Amsterdam, Utrecht University

Amsterdam and Utrecht Moved from Individual Reviews to an Institutional Pause

Published · 5 min read

Two Dutch universities initially examined Israeli collaborations one by one. Their later statements adopted a broader rule against new institutional ties while preserving individual contacts and most existing research. The dates matter: these were changes of policy, not a single nationwide boycott.

In 60 seconds

Two Dutch universities first reviewed their links with Israeli institutions one by one. In 2025 both moved to a broader rule: no new institutional partnerships, while individual contacts and most existing research continue. It was a change of university policy, not a national boycott. In October 2026, Utrecht confirmed it had left one project involving the Israeli Ministry of Health.

Summary

  • In October 2024, Utrecht said its review gave it no reason to stop ongoing research collaborations. In May 2025, it suspended new collaborations and terminated its Haifa exchange while allowing temporary research projects to continue.
  • Amsterdam’s March 2025 decision concerned three specific collaborations, including a Hebrew University exchange. By October, its board and deans said they would enter no new institutional collaborations with Israeli partners.
  • Existing consortia, new projects, student exchanges and individual academic contacts were treated differently. Neither institution’s statement supports the claim that every contact with every Israeli researcher ended.
  • Utrecht’s page now records a concrete follow-up: on October 15, 2026, it confirmed withdrawal from one project involving the Israeli Ministry of Health.

Utrecht’s first answer was no

The starting document is dated October 18, 2024. Utrecht University said it had completed an evaluation of collaborations with Israeli organizations, requesting external advice from the National Contact Point for Knowledge Security for some projects. The result was not an immediate break. “Based on these results, the Executive Board currently sees no reason to freeze or stop ongoing research collaborations,” the announcement said.

Student exchange was already constrained, but not for the same reason. There had been no outbound exchange since early October 2023 because of negative travel advice. Contracts with Hebrew University and Reichman University had expired, so those destinations were removed from the website. Haifa would not open for the 2025–26 exchange round because of the travel advice. An expired contract, a safety restriction and a political decision not to collaborate can produce the same empty exchange page. They should not be reported as interchangeable events.

The distinction became more important when Utrecht changed course. Its May 16, 2025 statement announced a halt to new collaborations, the termination of university-wide institutional relationships and the end of the Haifa exchange. It did not say the 2024 project reviews had suddenly proved incorrect. Instead, it described a changed judgment about the wider situation and the institution’s responsibilities.

President Anton Pijpers said recent Israeli government statements and actions concerning Gaza, displacement and aid blockades “have prompted us to tighten our policy on collaboration.” He added: “Authoritative scientific research speaks of genocidal violence.” That is the university’s explanation of its decision, not a legal finding made by this article.

Amsterdam’s individual approach

Amsterdam’s announcement of March 13, 2025 was explicitly designed to avoid a country-wide rule. Its Advisory Committee on Collaboration with Third Parties had considered three cases involving partners in China, Israel and Hungary. The university said the assessment was “never aimed at an entire country or institution: only individual collaborations are assessed.”

For the Hebrew University student exchange, the committee gave negative advice on continuation. It left open a re-examination if risk-reducing measures could be implemented. The board accepted that advice and said it would explore whether a renewed agreement could be designed. Rector Peter-Paul Verbeek put the principle plainly: the university wanted to protect knowledge security and avoid contributing to human-rights violations, “but also ensure we do not exclude entire countries.”

That announcement was not a decision to suspend all research with Israel. It was an exchange decision within a framework also applied to other countries. A record-based account has to preserve that fact, even though the university’s policy subsequently broadened.

The broader pause

The October 15, 2025 letter from Amsterdam’s Executive Board and deans described the next stage. Before the summer, they had decided not to begin new Horizon Europe research projects with Israeli partners while awaiting an investigation into the human-rights clause of the EU–Israel Association Agreement. At the end of September they upheld that decision and added a pause on other new institutional education and research collaborations.

The letter also said the university would explore the legal scope for withdrawing from existing Horizon collaborations. That was an intention to investigate exit options, not a declaration that every consortium had already been left. Similarly, Amsterdam said it would take no steps for the time being to extend the Tel Aviv student-exchange agreement, which expired the following year. Non-renewal should be followed to its effective date rather than treated as an immediate cancellation.

The board acknowledged a limit to its reasoning: “We cannot and do not want to hold Israeli institutions responsible for the actions of the Israeli government.” It nevertheless said it could not rule out institutional collaboration contributing directly or indirectly to human-rights violations. The letter also conceded that the decision would not itself change the situation in Gaza and Israel, describing the university’s influence as too limited.

What continued

Individual contacts were expressly protected in Amsterdam’s letter. “Academic freedom is crucial, especially at the individual level,” it said, keeping connections with individual students and researchers open and noting that many were critical of their government.

Utrecht drew a different operational boundary around its existing projects. Its May 2025 page described nine temporary research collaborations, individually evaluated in 2024, and said those evaluations found no contribution to military applications or deterioration in the human-rights situation. The projects were therefore not to be discontinued, with one exception: a project involving the Israeli government through the Ministry of Health. Utrecht intended to withdraw and was investigating whether it could do so. An update dated October 15, 2026 says it has now withdrawn from that specific project.

The page retains both the original summary and the later update. The figure of nine belongs to the earlier description; it should not be presented as a fresh count of projects still running after the withdrawal. Nor does the update disclose the financial cost or scientific consequences of leaving. Those are questions for the consortium and university, not figures to infer from the policy statement.

The policy is the event; implementation is the next story

This record contains two distinct developments. First came a shift from project-level assessments to a broader institutional presumption against new collaboration. Then came a slower process of implementing that presumption within existing agreements. Student mobility could end through non-renewal or termination; consortium participation could involve legal and contractual constraints; individual cooperation could remain permitted throughout.

For the site’s case database, each should be a separate decision with a follow-up field. Amsterdam’s examination of legal exit options remains an open reporting task in the documents reviewed here. Utrecht’s Ministry of Health withdrawal can be marked implemented, with the update date attached. Neither record establishes that the campus protests alone caused the change: both boards cite developments in Gaza and their institutional assessments. Protesters’ demands, board reasoning and the eventual operational effects need their own columns.

Sources

  1. Utrecht University, “Evaluation of collaborations with Israeli organizations completed,” October 18, 2024
  2. Utrecht University, “Utrecht University will not enter into any new collaborations with Israeli organizations until further notice,” May 16, 2025, with October 15, 2026 update
  3. University of Amsterdam, “UvA follows committee’s advice on three international collaborations,” March 13, 2025
  4. University of Amsterdam, “Why we will not collaborate with Israel at this time,” October 15, 2025

Further reading

Topics: research ties, legal outcome, follow-up.

For journalists and researchers

Primary documents

Cite this

Researchez. “Amsterdam and Utrecht Moved from Individual Reviews to an Institutional Pause.” Researchez, November 18, 2026. https://www.middleeastinfo.org/article-amsterdam-utrecht-moved-individual-reviews-institutional.

Researchez. (2026, November 18). Amsterdam and Utrecht Moved from Individual Reviews to an Institutional Pause. Researchez. https://www.middleeastinfo.org/article-amsterdam-utrecht-moved-individual-reviews-institutional

https://www.middleeastinfo.org/article-amsterdam-utrecht-moved-individual-reviews-institutional

Reuse

This report may be republished in full and without changes under CC BY-ND 4.0, with the credit line on Republish our work. Translations, edits and exclusive or paid use are by agreement: contact@www.middleeastinfo.org.

Updates and corrections

Changes to this report are noted at the end of the article with their date, and listed on Corrections.