Editorial illustration.
Editorial illustration.
In Depth · United Kingdom · Birmingham, Nottingham, University of London, Trinity and St John’s (Cambridge), Oxford

How Britain’s Encampments Ended: In Court, Not in Riot Gear

Published · 5 min read

American campuses called the police. British universities, a HEPI study found, mostly waited and then went to the High Court. Four judgments from 2024 and 2025 show how the law of trespass, not public-order policing, set the terms for protest on campus land.

In 60 seconds

In spring 2024, protest camps appeared at 36 British universities. Most universities waited, then went to court instead of calling the police. Judges granted possession orders in Birmingham, Nottingham and London, and injunctions in Cambridge, mainly under the law of trespass. Oxford was the exception: police arrested 16 people there. These cases set the rules for protest on campus land.

Summary

  • Encampments appeared at 36 UK higher-education institutions in spring 2024, peaking on May 30, according to a HEPI report based on 41 interviews with 57 people. “Most UK institutions were reluctant to take legal action unless absolutely necessary,” it found, partly because of the scenes at Columbia.
  • The University of Birmingham won a summary possession order on July 9, 2024. The judge accepted the camp had been “largely peaceful” but held it had no real prospect of defending a trespass claim, and extended the order beyond the occupied lawn to the whole of the university’s land.
  • Nottingham won a parallel order the same day covering the whole of Jubilee Campus. The University of London obtained a possession order on August 2, 2024 and, after the camp moved twice, an interim precautionary injunction on November 25, 2024.
  • In June 2025, Trinity College and St John’s College, Cambridge obtained final injunctions until the end of the 2026 exam season. The judge noted, “There is no suggestion anywhere in the evidence that any violence occurred.” The issue was noise during exams.
  • The main exception to the courtroom pattern was Oxford, where Thames Valley Police arrested 16 people on May 23, 2024, after protesters entered the university’s Wellington Square offices.

“Don’t call in the NYPD”

Josh Freeman, policy manager at the Higher Education Policy Institute, interviewed student protesters, vice-chancellors, senior managers, students’ union officers and Jewish students for HEPI Report 185, published in January 2025. At least one person was interviewed at 24 of the 36 institutions that had a camp. The title came from a protester: “There was nothing to do but take action.”

Freeman’s account of the institutional response is direct. “The difficult events at the University of Columbia meant most UK institutions were reluctant to take legal action unless absolutely necessary. At one institution, staff were told: ‘Don’t call in the NYPD.’” Instead, universities “having swapped tips with each other” adopted “a relatively uniform approach: allow encampments until they pose a risk to the normal functioning of the university … and then move to evict them.”

A minority moved faster. One interviewee described notices handed to campers “at 7am on the first day saying the encampment was illegal.” Those institutions, the report notes, “were able to take out court orders covering the entire campus, precluding a return by the encampment in the autumn.” It warned of the risks: the approach “may have been (or been seen as) unnecessarily punitive.”

The report also records the effect on Jewish students, who described consequences “from discomfort at having to see the encampment every day to feeling fearful and intimidated.” One community representative told HEPI: “People felt very on edge. They’d had enough – they were not feeling at home at a place that should feel like home.”

Birmingham: the template judgment

The camp on The Green Heart, an open lawn at the center of Birmingham’s Edgbaston campus and “the main site for graduation celebrations,” began “from the early hours of 9 May 2024.” The evidence, the judge recorded, “suggests there were 61 tents on The Green Heart on 3 June 2024, rising to 83 by 20 June 2024.”

The defense was led by Ms Ali, who “describes herself as a British-Pakistani Muslim woman and one of the University’s undergraduate students.” She argued discrimination, breach of the public-sector equality duty, breach of the free-speech duty in section 43 of the Education (No. 2) Act 1986, and breach of her rights to expression and assembly under Articles 10 and 11 of the European Convention.

The university’s evidence included a record of tolerance: in 2020, 2021 and 2022, “requests were made for a total of 1,596 events,” and “permission was granted in all cases.” Its own message to staff had said the camp “has been largely peaceful to date” but caused disruption.

The judgment, handed down on July 9, 2024 after a hearing on July 4, rejected every ground. “There is no real prospect of Ms Ali successfully showing that the University has discriminated against her,” it says, nor that “a possession order would be incompatible with her Convention rights.” The more consequential holding was on scope. Although there was no camp elsewhere, the court noted an earlier occupation of Chancellor’s Court and the “potential where a possession order is made in only one limited area for a camp simply to move.” It made the order for the whole Edgbaston campus, Selly Oak and the Exchange Building.

Nottingham: the same day, the same reasoning

The Nottingham case was heard on July 5 and decided on July 9. The lead defendant, River Butterworth, was the outgoing postgraduate officer of the students’ union. The court adopted the Birmingham reasoning on scope: “the order for possession should be in respect of the whole of the Jubilee Campus rather than just the site of the camp.”

University of London: following a moving camp

The University of London case shows what happened when a possession order covered only part of the land. The protests were aimed at SOAS, a separate legal entity, but took place “in very large part” on the University of London’s land in Bloomsbury. After a possession order of August 2, 2024, the protesters “relocated and established a second encampment” on other University of London land. When enforcement agents cleared that, they “immediately move[d] to a third encampment on nearby land owned by the local authority, Camden.”

Mr Justice Thompsell granted an interim precautionary injunction on November 25, 2024. His reasoning on the balance of harm is the clearest statement in the four cases of what such orders do and do not take away: “if the injunction is granted then the loss of the Defendants is small. They will still be able to protest,” though they would need to plan protests “in advance” under the university’s code.

Cambridge 2025: noise in exam season

The latest of the cases came a year after the first wave. “Shortly before 18.00 on Friday, 30 May 2025,” protesters from Cambridge for Palestine began to gather on Newton’s Lawn, next to Trinity College’s main entrance. Trinity’s evidence “concentrated on the disruptive impact of loud noise on students taking examinations.” Its main exam period ran from May 26 to June 20, and it included exams for students “who require special arrangements because of disability or mental health concerns.”

Rajah J granted an urgent interim injunction, served at about 8 a.m. on June 2. The protesters obeyed it and by 1 p.m. had moved to a lawn next to St John’s College chapel. St John’s obtained its own injunction. At the return hearing on June 5, Andrew Twigger KC, sitting as a deputy High Court judge, heard both colleges’ claims. The European Legal Support Center intervened and argued that the noise was limited and many activities “were quiet (such as crafts, banner-making and knot-tying).”

The judge’s finding on violence was unequivocal: “There is no suggestion anywhere in the evidence that any violence occurred.” He nonetheless granted final injunctions running to the end of June 2026, the end of the next exam season. In an addendum he narrowed the orders: he struck out wording that would have reached obstructions on the public highway outside the colleges, and required court permission before any contempt application against an unnamed defendant.

Oxford: the exception

The one major police operation was at Oxford. On May 23, 2024, Times Higher Education reported, Thames Valley Police said it had been called to Wellington Square after protesters “had gained access to a private office”; “16 people had been arrested on suspicion of aggravated trespass, with one of these also detained on suspicion of common assault.” The university said a receptionist had been “physically handl[ed].”

What the cases established

  • Trespass, not protest law, was the tool. None of the judgments found that the universities had banned protest; all turned on unauthorized occupation of land.
  • Scope can be wide. Birmingham and Nottingham won campus-wide orders without a camp anywhere else, because of the risk the camp would move.
  • Free-speech duties were argued and lost at the summary stage. The Office for Students’ guidance now says providers must take “reasonably practicable steps” to secure lawful speech, but adds that if a protest “prevents teaching or learning, then it is unlikely to be reasonably practicable to permit it to take place then and there.”

Sources

  1. Josh Freeman, “’There was nothing to do but take action’: The encampments protesting for Palestine and the response to them,” HEPI Report 185, January 2025
  2. University of Birmingham v Persons Unknown and Ali [2024] EWHC 1770 (KB), July 9, 2024
  3. University of Nottingham v Butterworth [2024] EWHC 1771 (KB), July 9, 2024
  4. University of London v Harvie-Clark and others [2024] EWHC 2895 (Ch), November 25, 2024
  5. Trinity College, Cambridge v Persons Unknown (with St John’s College) [2025] EWHC 1577 (Ch)
  6. Times Higher Education, “Police arrest 16 as pro-Palestinian sit-in cleared at Oxford,” May 2024
  7. Office for Students, “Regulating or restricting speech.”

Further reading

Topics: encampment, legal outcome.

For journalists and researchers

Primary documents

Cite this

Researchez. “How Britain’s Encampments Ended: In Court, Not in Riot Gear.” Researchez, November 18, 2026. https://www.middleeastinfo.org/article-britains-encampments-ended-court-not-riot.

Researchez. (2026, November 18). How Britain’s Encampments Ended: In Court, Not in Riot Gear. Researchez. https://www.middleeastinfo.org/article-britains-encampments-ended-court-not-riot

https://www.middleeastinfo.org/article-britains-encampments-ended-court-not-riot

Reuse

This report may be republished in full and without changes under CC BY-ND 4.0, with the credit line on Republish our work. Translations, edits and exclusive or paid use are by agreement: contact@www.middleeastinfo.org.

Updates and corrections

Changes to this report are noted at the end of the article with their date, and listed on Corrections.