
Berlin Brought Back Expulsion for Students. Two Years Later, Four Schools Still Cannot Use It.
A 2024 law let Berlin universities discipline students again, after an assault on a Jewish student. The Senate does not count the cases, and the assault trial has turned on a question the new rules do not answer.
In 60 seconds
In 2024, after a Jewish student at the Free University was assaulted, Berlin brought back a law that lets universities expel students, but only after a final criminal conviction. Each university must first adopt its own procedures: by June 2026, seven universities and the Charité had, and four had not. The city does not record how often the law has been used, so no figure exists. The assault case is still in the courts after an appeal reduced the sentence.
Summary
- Berlin abolished its university disciplinary law in 2021. After a Jewish Free University student was assaulted in February 2024, the city parliament restored it on July 4, 2024. Exmatriculation is now possible only after a final criminal conviction, and is followed by a two-year bar on re-enrolling.
- Universities cannot use the law without first adopting a procedural statute. As of June 19, 2026, the Senate listed seven universities plus the Charité as having done so, and four arts and technical universities as not.
- The Senate told parliament in May 2025 that individual disciplinary cases are “not systematically recorded.” No public figure exists for how often the law has been used.
- The assault trial ended at first instance in April 2025 with a three-year sentence and a finding of antisemitic motive. On appeal in April 2026 the sentence was cut to two years and six months and the motive was found not proven. Prosecutors have asked the Kammergericht to review the ruling.
The gap the law was meant to close
Until 2021, Berlin universities had a disciplinary code whose most severe sanction was exmatriculation. That year an amendment to the Berlin Higher Education Act removed it. The Free University later explained the consequence in a public FAQ on the December 2023 protests: expulsion was “formally not possible,” and the university could only impose measures against disruption, such as house bans, for at most three months.
That became a political issue after February 2, 2024. According to the Tiergarten local court, a fellow student attacked a Jewish student he knew from the university outside a bar in Berlin-Mitte that night. The court found that the defendant shouted that the victim was the one tearing down posters at the university, punched him in the face, and, once he was on the ground, kicked him in the face. The victim suffered a complex midface fracture and a brain bleed; the court described the injuries as potentially life-threatening. The victim, Lahav Shapira, has spoken publicly about the case and joined the proceedings as a co-plaintiff.
The court said the background was that the victim, as administrator of a student chat group, had deleted openly antisemitic posts and had removed antisemitic posters linked to the Middle East conflict.
What the 2024 law says
The Senate presented its draft on March 26, 2024, and the Abgeordnetenhaus passed it at its last session before the summer break, on July 4, 2024. It was published in the state law gazette as the 17th amendment of the Higher Education Act.
The new § 16 defines five kinds of disciplinary offense, each requiring a connection to the university:
- significantly impairing a university member by physical violence, calls for violence or threats of violence;
- being finally convicted of an intentional crime against a member of the university, where the nature of the crime threatens that member’s studies or work;
- using university facilities for intentional crimes that cause the university significant harm;
- sexual harassment that significantly impairs a member;
- violating a member’s dignity on grounds listed in Berlin’s anti-discrimination law, in a way that creates an intimidating or hostile environment and threatens that member’s studies or work.
The available measures, in ascending order, are a reprimand, a threat of exmatriculation, exclusion from certain facilities including digital ones, exclusion from individual courses for up to one semester, and exmatriculation. Two limits stand out. For the first four offenses, exmatriculation is allowed only on the basis of a final criminal conviction. For the discrimination offense, neither the threat of exmatriculation nor exmatriculation may be imposed at all. A student who is exmatriculated may not re-enroll at the same university for two years.
Separately, the law lengthened university presidents’ power to bar students for disruption. According to the parliament’s report on the vote, such a ban can now last up to nine months “in extreme cases,” where the previous limit was three.
A law that needs a statute first
§ 16(3) requires each university to adopt a statute governing the disciplinary procedure and to notify the Senate before it takes effect. A 2026 parliamentary question stated that without such a statute no disciplinary procedure is permissible, and the Senate’s answer did not dispute it.
That requirement has slowed the law down. In May 2025, ten months after the vote, a CDU member asked which universities had a statute. The Senate replied that the statutes “are being drafted” and would then go through university bodies. Asked whether the law had already been applied, it said individual cases “are not systematically recorded” by the Senate administration. It gave the same answer to questions on house bans and on recovering the costs of occupations.
By June 19, 2026, the picture had moved. In answer to another CDU question, the Senate listed statutes at Humboldt University, the Free University, the Technical University, HTW, HWR, the Alice Salomon University and the Ernst Busch drama school, and noted that the Charité had published one too. Four had not published one: the University of the Arts, the Hanns Eisler music school, Weißensee art school and the Berliner Hochschule für Technik. The Senate said the law sets no deadline and that it expected the remaining statutes “soon.”
No public source reviewed for this report gives the number of disciplinary procedures opened, measures imposed or exmatriculations ordered under the new law.
The trial: same facts, different finding on motive
The criminal case moved on its own track. On April 17, 2025, the Tiergarten court sentenced the defendant, then 24 and a former teacher-training student, to three years for dangerous bodily harm. The court called the antisemitic motive “the central aggravating factor” and found it proven despite the defendant’s denial. It cited items in his apartment denying Israel’s right to exist, his prior messages to the victim and a video on his phone. “Antisemitism is not an opinion,” the presiding judge said.
On April 13, 2026, the Berlin I regional court decided the appeal. According to LTO, it agreed with the legal classification, which was dangerous bodily harm committed with a dangerous instrument (the shod foot) and in a life-threatening manner. It reduced the sentence by six months, to two years and six months. The difference was motive. Under § 46(2) of the Criminal Code, antisemitic motives are an aggravating factor; the word “antisemitic” was added to that list in 2021. The appeal chamber found that such a motive had not been proven after three days of evidence. LTO reported that the court weighed in the defendant’s favor that he had no prior record, regretted the act, was in therapy and had apologized to the victim. Because the sentence still exceeds two years, it cannot be suspended.
Prosecutors had asked for two years and eleven months. On April 16, 2026, the Berliner Zeitung reported that they had filed a revision, asking the Kammergericht to review the judgment.
What the two tracks show together
The assault case has not yet produced a final conviction, so the law’s strictest measure would not yet be available against the defendant even if it applied. Whether it applies at all depends on facts this report could not verify, including the defendant’s enrollment status after the attack and whether the Free University used house bans in the interim.
The law’s design also matters here. It ties the heaviest sanction to the criminal courts, and it excludes exmatriculation for discriminatory conduct that falls short of a crime. The science committee heard experts on the reform on April 15, 2024, and the verbatim record of that hearing is public.
Open questions for follow-up
- How many disciplinary procedures have the eight institutions with statutes opened since adopting them, and with what results? (Requests to each university.)
- Will the Senate begin recording cases, as several written questions have asked?
- When will the Kammergericht rule on the revision?
Sources
- Freie Universität Berlin, FAQ on protest actions, December 2023 (exmatriculation abolished in 2021)
- Berlin Senate press release, March 26, 2024
- Berlin.de (dpa), “Landesparlament beschließt verschärftes Hochschulgesetz,” July 5, 2024
- Gesetz- und Verordnungsblatt für Berlin, 2024, p. 461 (17th amendment of the BerlHG)
- Abgeordnetenhaus Berlin, written answer 19/22462, May 9, 2025
- Abgeordnetenhaus Berlin, written answer 19/26345, June 19, 2026
- Abgeordnetenhaus Berlin, Science Committee verbatim record 19/32, April 15, 2024
- Amtsgericht Tiergarten, press release 18/2025, April 17, 2025
- Legal Tribune Online on the appeal judgment, Landgericht Berlin I, 567 NBs 66/25, April 13, 2026
- Berliner Zeitung, “Staatsanwaltschaft Berlin legt Revision ein,” April 16, 2026
For journalists and researchers
Primary documents
- Freie Universität Berlin, FAQ on protest actions, December 2023 (exmatriculation abolished in 2021)
- Berlin Senate press release, March 26, 2024
- Berlin.de (dpa), “Landesparlament beschließt verschärftes Hochschulgesetz,” July 5, 2024
- Gesetz- und Verordnungsblatt für Berlin, 2024, p. 461 (17th amendment of the BerlHG)
- Abgeordnetenhaus Berlin, written answer 19/22462, May 9, 2025
- Abgeordnetenhaus Berlin, written answer 19/26345, June 19, 2026
- Abgeordnetenhaus Berlin, Science Committee verbatim record 19/32, April 15, 2024
- Amtsgericht Tiergarten, press release 18/2025, April 17, 2025
Cite this
Researchez. “Berlin Brought Back Expulsion for Students. Two Years Later, Four Schools Still Cannot Use It.” Researchez, November 18, 2026. https://www.middleeastinfo.org/article-berlin-brought-back-expulsion-students-two.
Researchez. (2026, November 18). Berlin Brought Back Expulsion for Students. Two Years Later, Four Schools Still Cannot Use It. Researchez. https://www.middleeastinfo.org/article-berlin-brought-back-expulsion-students-two
https://www.middleeastinfo.org/article-berlin-brought-back-expulsion-students-two
Reuse
This report may be republished in full and without changes under CC BY-ND 4.0, with the credit line on Republish our work. Translations, edits and exclusive or paid use are by agreement: contact@www.middleeastinfo.org.
Updates and corrections
Changes to this report are noted at the end of the article with their date, and listed on Corrections.