Editorial illustration.
Editorial illustration.
In Depth · Germany · Policing and the courts

Berlin Shut Down the Palestine Congress After an Hour. Two Courts Have Since Said It Went Too Far.

Police cut the power to a video address, dissolved a three-day assembly and banned its continuation. A judge found no violated restriction and no criminal speech, and a second ruling on a barred speaker is now final.

Summary

  • On April 12, 2024, Berlin police dissolved the “Palestine Congress 2024”, planned as a three-day indoor assembly. Shortly after it opened, a video message by a speaker who had been barred from taking part was played, and police cut the power and banned the next two days.
  • On November 26, 2025, the Berlin administrative court ruled the dissolution and the ban unlawful (VG 1 K 187/24). It found that no prior restriction had been breached and that police had established no criminal speech. It also said milder steps, such as excluding individual speakers, should have been considered.
  • In a separate case, the court ruled on July 14, 2025 that the immigration office’s ban on political activity against the British-Palestinian surgeon Ghassan Abu-Sittah was unlawful. On November 6, 2025 the higher administrative court rejected Berlin’s application to appeal, so that ruling is final.
  • The first ruling can still be challenged by an application for leave to appeal. This report did not establish whether Berlin has filed one.

What happened on April 12, 2024

The congress was registered as an assembly in closed rooms, scheduled for April 12 to 14, 2024, under the subtitle “Wir klagen an” (“We accuse”). According to the legal news service LTO, the organizer was the Berlin association Jüdische Stimme für einen gerechten Frieden in Nahost (Jewish Voice for a Just Peace in the Middle East). LTO reported that security agencies and the Berlin interior administration considered most of the supporting groups to belong to the boycott spectrum.

The authorities acted before the doors opened. According to the administrative court’s press release, police imposed a number of restrictions in advance, including a ban on certain slogans. The State Office for Immigration barred several of the planned speakers from taking part, on the ground that they could be expected to commit speech offenses.

One of those speakers was the Palestinian historian Salman Abu Sitta. LTO reported that before the congress he had praised the “determination and courage” of those who carried out the October 7, 2023 attack. LTO also reported that entry bans had been imposed on him, on the surgeon Ghassan Abu-Sittah and on the Greek politician Yanis Varoufakis. It said some of those measures were later found unlawful by German courts in part.

Shortly after the assembly began, a video message from Salman Abu Sitta was played. Police then cut the power to the video transmission, dissolved the assembly and prohibited its continuation on the following days. The organizer sued for a declaration that the dissolution and the ban were unlawful.

What the court decided

The 1st chamber of the Berlin administrative court found for the organizer. In its press release of November 26, 2025, the court said the dissolution and the ban were “in any event disproportionate.”

The court gave three reasons. First, none of the restrictions imposed in advance had been violated up to the point of dissolution. Second, police had not established that any criminal speech offense had been committed. Third, it was not apparent that police had seriously considered milder, equally effective measures, “such as excluding individual speakers and participants,” which in the court’s words “would have been obvious here.” Police had not shown that such steps would have failed, the court said.

Police had based the ban on § 22(1) no. 3 of Berlin’s assembly law. LTO describes this provision as allowing restriction, prohibition or dissolution of an indoor assembly where there is an immediate danger that statements amounting to a serious crime or an offense prosecuted by the state will be made. The court left open whether that condition was met. It decided the case on proportionality.

According to LTO, this was the first ruling on whether the police acted lawfully at the scene, as distinct from the entry and participation bans issued beforehand.

The speaker who was not allowed to speak

The second case concerned Ghassan Abu-Sittah. He is a British-Palestinian surgeon who, according to LTO, treated injured people in Gaza for about a month from October 2023 for Médecins Sans Frontières. The federal police refused him entry at the airport. The immigration office also prohibited him from taking part in the congress, including by telecommunication, and from publishing or giving interviews about it. The office’s stated concern was that he might glorify the October 7 attack and advocate the destruction of Israel.

German law allows such a ban on a foreign national’s political activity. Under § 47(2) no. 1 of the Residence Act, it applies where the activity endangers the free democratic basic order or the security of the Federal Republic, or contravenes codified norms of international law.

On July 14, 2025 the Berlin administrative court found the ban unlawful (VG 24 K 493/24). According to LTO’s account of the ruling, his public statements since October 7 did not support the forecast of danger. The office had cited no criminally relevant statements and no acts of support for terrorist organizations, and older statements in which he appeared sympathetic to Hamas were not decisive. The court added that even if a danger had existed, the ban would have been disproportionate. The office should have weighed his role as an eyewitness to the strikes of October and November 2023, on which he had been heard by the International Criminal Court.

Berlin applied for leave to appeal. On November 6, 2025 the higher administrative court of Berlin-Brandenburg rejected the application (OVG 2 N 287/25). Its press release said Berlin’s grounds did not even meet the legal requirement to engage with the lower court’s reasoning, so the court did not review the merits. The July ruling is final.

Two different people, two different measures

The two cases are easy to confuse. Salman Abu Sitta, the historian whose video prompted the shutdown, and Ghassan Abu-Sittah, the surgeon whose activity ban was struck down, are different people. The two cases also concern different authorities and different laws. The congress case is about the police and the state assembly law. The surgeon’s case is about the immigration office and the federal Residence Act.

Neither ruling says the authorities were wrong to be concerned about what might be said. In the congress case, the court explicitly left open whether the threshold for intervention had been reached. Both rulings say the measures chosen went further than the facts allowed.

What remains open

The November 2025 judgment could be challenged by an application to the higher administrative court for leave to appeal. This report did not find a public record of whether Berlin filed one. The court’s full written reasons were not available in public databases at the time of writing.

The rulings also leave open questions that only the Berlin authorities can answer: how many officers were deployed on April 12, 2024, what the operation cost, and whether any of the other entry or activity bans issued that week remain in force. In earlier written answers, Berlin’s Senate said police deployments are paid from the regular budget and their costs are not recorded separately, and that deployments and officer-hours for Israel- and Gaza-related assemblies could not be retrieved automatically.

Sources

  1. Verwaltungsgericht Berlin, press release no. 51/2025, November 26, 2025, judgment VG 1 K 187/24
  2. Legal Tribune Online, “VG Berlin: Auflösung des ‘Palästina-Kongresses’ rechtswidrig,” November 26, 2025
  3. Legal Tribune Online, “VG Berlin zum Palästina-Kongress: Betätigungsverbot für Arzt war rechtswidrig,” July 15, 2025 (judgment VG 24 K 493/24 of July 14, 2025)
  4. Oberverwaltungsgericht Berlin-Brandenburg, press release 34/25, November 6, 2025, order OVG 2 N 287/25
  5. Berlin Senate, written answers 19/12014 and 19/20132 (police costs and officer-hours) · link 2