Editorial illustration.
Editorial illustration.
In Depth · United States · Columbia University, New York

Columbia’s Own Compliance Report Tells the Story of a Quieter Campus

Fifteen months after agreeing to pay $221 million to settle federal claims, Columbia reports that no demonstration in the 2025–26 academic year led to a rules charge. The report also shows how far the university’s disciplinary machinery was rebuilt to get there.

Summary

  • Columbia was the first and largest test case. On March 7, 2025, four federal agencies canceled about $400 million in grants and contracts; the Justice Department noted the university held “more than $5 billion in federal grant commitments.”
  • The July 2025 resolution agreement committed Columbia to $200 million in equal annual installments and a $21 million fund administered with the EEOC, under an independent Resolution Monitor.
  • Columbia’s October 2026 semi-annual report says the second installment has been paid and rates 20 of the 23 obligations it tracks “Satisfied to Date” and one, the appointment of an Administrator, “Complete.” Two academic items, the regional-studies review starting with the Middle East and new joint faculty appointments, remain “In Progress.”
  • The University Judicial Board now sits in the Provost’s office, its panels limited to faculty and administrators. The Office of Institutional Equity reports a 32% fall in incident reports and a 27% fall in cases in 2025–26.
  • The report states: “none of the demonstrations that took place at University facilities or University-sponsored activities led to charges of Rules violations.” It does not say how many demonstrations took place.

Where it started

On April 17, 2024, Columbia’s president, Minouche Shafik, appeared before the House Committee on Education and the Workforce alongside two trustees and a law-school professor. Claire Shipman, co-chair of the board, told the committee that the university had “rewritten our rules, beefed up our enforcement process” and had “suspended two student groups for noncompliance, more than a dozen individual students, and we disciplined faculty members.” Pressed by the chair, Shafik put the figure higher: “we have already suspended 15 students from Columbia. We have six on disciplinary probation.”

The next day police cleared the first encampment on South Lawn. ACLED, the conflict-data project, later wrote that “the arrest of over 100 students at Columbia University in New York around 18 April heralded a new wave of campus demonstrations across 36 states.” Shafik stepped down effective August 14, 2024, writing that the period “has taken a considerable toll on my family.” Katrina Armstrong, the chief executive of Columbia’s medical center, became interim president.

The cancellation

The pressure that produced the settlement arrived in March 2025. The Departments of Justice, Health and Human Services and Education and the General Services Administration announced “the immediate cancellation of approximately $400 million in federal grants and contracts” over what they called “the school’s continued inaction in the face of persistent harassment of Jewish students.” The release described the move as a “notice to every school and university that receives federal dollars.”

On July 23, 2025, Columbia and the government signed a resolution agreement. The White House fact sheet described the deal as Columbia agreeing to pay $200 million and to enforce “strict rules against disruptive protests, prohibiting masked protests, and maintaining trained security officers and ongoing cooperation with the New York Police Department.” The agreement text is narrower on masks than the fact sheet; the university’s later reporting frames it as policies on “masking and required identification expectations,” with discipline for noncompliance.

What the October 2026 report says

Columbia files a semi-annual report to the Resolution Monitor, Charles J. Cooper of Cooper & Kirk. The October 2026 edition is 49 pages and grades each obligation as “Complete,” “Satisfied to Date,” “In Progress” or “Not Yet Required / Not Applicable.”

Money. “Columbia has made the second installment payment towards the $200 million sum and funded the EEOC settlement fund,” the report says. The deadline to file claims with the EEOC fund was June 2, 2026.

Discipline. Paragraph 26 of the agreement moved the University Judicial Board, which hears serious conduct cases, out of its old shared-governance structure. According to the report, “The University Judicial Board (UJB) and Rules process are now housed in and administered by the Office of the Provost. Each UJB panel is comprised solely of faculty and administrative staff members.” The Provost approves every panel member and appellate dean; final appeals rest with the president. The report adds that panel members are not told a respondent’s immigration status and may not consider it.

Demonstrations. Under Paragraph 27, protest “inside academic buildings” is “not acceptable” and subject to discipline, and any discriminatory conduct at a demonstration falls under the anti-harassment policy. The single most quotable line in the report follows: “in the 2025-2026 academic year, none of the demonstrations that took place at University facilities or University-sponsored activities led to charges of Rules violations.”

Complaints. The Office of Institutional Equity reported “a 32% decrease in Incident Reports and a 27% decrease in Cases” compared with the year before. Reports alleging antisemitism, anti-Arab, anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian discrimination “also declined following elevated reporting in the prior two academic years.”

Academic programs. The most sensitive obligation is still open. Paragraph 12 requires a senior vice provost to review “the portfolio of programs in regional areas across the University, starting with the Middle East,” naming the Center for Palestine Studies, the Institute for Israel and Jewish Studies, the Middle Eastern, South Asian, and African Studies department, the Middle East Institute and the Tel Aviv and Amman global hubs. The report says the review began in summer 2025 with a faculty committee and rates it “In Progress.”

Reading the numbers carefully

A decline in complaints and charges can mean less conflict, less reporting, or both. The report offers no independent count of campus demonstrations in 2025–26, and the zero-charges line covers only demonstrations “at University facilities or University-sponsored activities.” Off-campus actions by Columbia students are outside its scope. The Office of Institutional Equity’s annual report, cited as evidence, should be checked for the raw numbers behind the percentages.

There is also the question of authorship. The report is Columbia’s own account of its compliance. The monitor’s assessment, if published, would be the independent check.

Ledger

DateEventSource
April 17, 2024House hearing; Shafik cites 15 suspensionsHouse transcript
April 18, 2024South Lawn cleared; more than 100 arrestsACLED
August 14, 2024Shafik resignation effectiveTeachers College (reproducing Columbia messages)
March 7, 2025~$400M canceledDOJ
July 23, 2025Resolution agreement: $200M + $21M EEOC fundWhite House; Columbia
October 1, 2026Semi-annual report: second installment paidColumbia report

Sources

  1. US House Committee on Education and the Workforce, “Columbia in Crisis” hearing transcript, April 17, 2024
  2. ACLED, “US Student Pro-Palestine Demonstrations Remain Overwhelmingly Peaceful,” May 2024
  3. Teachers College, Columbia University, “Columbia University Leadership Change,” August 16, 2024
  4. US Department of Justice et al., “Initial Cancelation of Grants and Contracts to Columbia University Worth $400 Million,” March 7, 2025
  5. The White House, “Fact Sheet: President Donald J. Trump Secures Major Settlement with Columbia University,” July 2025
  6. Columbia University, “Resolution Agreement: Semi-Annual Report,” October 2026
  7. Columbia University Resolution Agreement, July 2025. (columbia.edu pages block automated checks; the file loads in a browser)

Further reading

Topics: legal outcome, cost, research ties.