
Paid by the Job: The Hired Provocations in Paris, and the Bill Nobody Has Added Up
Red hands on a memorial, coffins at the Eiffel Tower, pig heads outside nine mosques. French intelligence says Russia hires people through intermediaries to do this, for 120 to 1,500 euros a job. Courts in Paris and Serbia have convicted some of them. What it costs the public has never been counted.
In 60 seconds
Since 2023, people have been paid to vandalize places in Paris, from a Holocaust memorial to mosques, in ways designed to cause anger and divide French society. French intelligence says Russian services hire them through middlemen, for a few hundred to 1,500 euros a job. One group was jailed in Paris in 2025, and courts in Serbia convicted three men over the pig heads left outside mosques. Each act sets off police work, site protection, investigations and trials. Nobody has said what that costs the public.
Key points
- Since October 2023, the Paris prosecutor’s office has linked nine cases of vandalism and staged provocations to foreign interference. French intelligence says they are carried out by paid “proxies” recruited through intermediaries.
- Fees disclosed in court, by police or in Serbian verdicts range from 120 to 1,500 euros a job, with travel and lodging paid.
- In the first case tried, four Bulgarians were sentenced in October 2025 to two to four years in prison; the court found “acts committed from abroad with a hostile aim.” Serbian verdicts in the pig heads case cite Russian intelligence. Court record
- No public cost has been published for any of the cases, and France keeps no public record of such acts.
On the night of May 13 to 14, 2024, someone painted close to 500 red hands on walls in the 4th and 5th arrondissements of Paris, 35 of them on the Mémorial de la Shoah (franceinfo). Seventeen months later, in a Paris courtroom, one of the men who did it explained his fee. He said he had painted the hands “in exchange for 1,000 euros.” The man who filmed them said he had been paid 500 euros (AP, via Arab News).
“This case is not the case of a tag on a wall. It is much more than that,” the prosecutor, Camille Poch, told the court (franceinfo, translated). “What matters is not the stone you throw into the water. It is the ripples that appear on the surface.” She described “a raid organized well in advance to ensure the greatest possible visibility” for the act.
The red hands were not an isolated act. They were the first of nine cases that the Paris prosecutor’s office has linked to foreign interference since October 2023 to come to trial (franceinfo). France’s domestic intelligence service, the DGSI, describes the method in a few words: “proxies,” people who do not work for the Russian services but who “carry out ad hoc tasks paid for by intermediaries, largely based in countries neighbouring Russia” (BBC). The fees that have come out in court and in police statements run from 120 to 1,500 euros a job. What the jobs have cost the French public in policing, protection, investigation and cleanup has never been published.
The red handsfranceinfo, verdict, October 31, 2025franceinfo, prosecution, October 30, 2025AP via Arab News, October 30, 2025BBC, September 11, 2025
A price list
The pattern is clearest when the cases are set side by side, cheapest first. In June 2024, five life-size coffins draped in the French flag were left near the Eiffel Tower. The driver who brought them told police he had been “paid 120 euros for this mission and the young men 400 euros,” according to a police source quoted by AFP (France 3, translated). All three said they were unemployed and needed money. An investigating judge placed the three people brought before him under the status of assisted witnesses rather than charging them with violence, the prosecutor’s office said; it treated the coffins as “a gesture of psychological violence,” an offense punishable by three years in prison and a 45,000 euro fine (France 3, translated). More than a year later, the prosecutor’s office said three men born in Bulgaria, Germany and Ukraine were suspected in the case and that a warrant had been issued for their arrest (AP via Arab News). One of the red hands defendants testified that he had first been recruited to transport the coffins, and backed out when he was told where they were to go.
In late October 2023, blue stars of David were stenciled on walls in the Paris region. A Moldovan couple caught in the act said they had acted “on the order of a third party and for payment,” which a conversation in Russian on their phone confirmed (Public Sénat, translated). They were expelled. The interior minister at the time, Gérald Darmanin, told the Senate there had in fact been two couples, that both had left the country, and that “a judicial investigation has been opened” (Public Sénat).
The red hands paid 1,000 euros to the painter and 500 to the cameraman, with travel and a hotel paid for by a third man, the court heard. For a series of attacks in Paris in spring 2025, including green paint thrown on three synagogues, the operatives were promised 1,000 euros each; for the pig heads left outside mosques in September 2025, 1,500 euros each, with travel and lodging paid, according to Serbian court verdicts seen by Forum 18.
These are small sums for the people paid. They buy a photograph, a news cycle and, each time, a public response that runs for months.
PaymentsFrance 3, June 3, 2024Public Sénat, November 15, 2023AP via Arab NewsForum 18, April 27, 2026
The trial
Four Bulgarian men were tried in Paris from October 29 to 31, 2025. The prosecution described one as the “logistician,” absent on the night but responsible for organizing it, and another as the “principal executor” and “recruiter,” who was still at large and was tried in his absence (franceinfo). The court convicted all four of aggravated damage, committed jointly and because of the supposed religion of the victims, and of criminal association. It sentenced them to between two and four years in prison, each with a permanent ban from French territory, and issued a warrant for the man still at large (franceinfo).
The court went further than the charges. It recognized a context of foreign interference and pointed to “acts committed from abroad with a hostile aim, to stir public opinion, to press on existing divisions in order to fragment French society a little more” (franceinfo, translated). It could not convict them of acting to serve a foreign power: that offense was created at the end of July 2024, after the red hands (franceinfo; the 2024 law). A defense lawyer objected even to the court’s finding of interference: “It bothers me a little, since the law postdates the acts” (franceinfo, translated).
The court did not name Russia, in the reports reviewed for this article. The DGSI did. In an assessment cited in a note from the prosecutor’s office, it said the operation could “correspond to an attempt to destabilize France orchestrated by the Russian intelligence services” (Politico).
The defendants talked about money. The painter “did not address accusations of Russian involvement,” AP reported. Another defendant told the court: “I did it for two reasons: the money and my own stupidity” (franceinfo, translated).
The Paris trialfranceinfo, October 30, 2025franceinfo, October 31, 2025Politico Europe, October 29, 2025Vie publique, law of July 25, 2024
Pig heads, and a verdict in Serbia
On September 9, 2025, pig heads were found outside nine mosques in Paris and its suburbs. Five had President Macron’s name written on them (AP via Arab News). The interior minister, Bruno Retailleau, expressed his “indignation”; the City of Paris filed a complaint (La Libre, translated).
The prosecutor’s office said the heads “were placed there by foreign nationals who immediately left the country, with the clear intention of causing unrest within the nation.” The aim, said the Paris prosecutor, Laure Beccuau, “is to unsettle our fellow citizens, ultimately raising questions about the country we live in, about their safety, and then, of course, creating divisions between communities” (Al Jazeera).
The arrests came in Serbia. On September 29, 2025, Serbian police detained 11 Serbian citizens. The interior ministry said a man who had fled had, “acting on instructions of a foreign intelligence service,” organized and trained the group in Serbia (N1, translated). It did not name the country. The Paris prosecutor’s office said the arrests had not been made in the framework of its own case (franceinfo).
Three of the men were convicted in Smederevo on plea agreements. Accounts of the sentences differ. La Croix reported, citing the court, sentences of house arrest of six, twelve and eighteen months. Forum 18, which saw the verdicts, reported that one man was sentenced to a year and a half in prison. Forum 18 and OCCRP both report that the verdicts say the men were directed by “structures of the intelligence service of the Russian Federation.” The investigation into eight others continues (La Croix).
In May 2026, OCCRP and Delfi Estonia published leaked documents that they say come from the Social Design Agency, a Russian firm already under U.S., UK and EU sanctions, and point to the Russian presidential administration. One is titled “Report on Operation Pig’s Head.” It says six operatives arrived in Paris on September 7, carried out “reconnaissance” on September 8, delivered the heads the following night and “successfully left the country” (OCCRP).
The mosquesLa Libre (AFP), September 9, 2025Al Jazeera, September 22, 2025N1, September 29, 2025franceinfo, September 30, 2025La Croix, March 6, 2026Forum 18, April 27, 2026OCCRP, May 2026
Across four borders
The method relies on people who arrive, act and leave. Three of the red hands defendants fled Paris the same morning by bus to Brussels and flew on to Sofia. Two were later arrested in Bulgaria and extradited to France; the man suspected of financing the operation was arrested in Croatia; the alleged ringleader is still at large (Politico).
The pig heads followed a similar route. A farmer in Normandy told police he had sold “about 10” pig heads to two men driving a car with Serbian plates. Investigators said the two used a Croatian mobile phone and crossed into Belgium a few hours later (BBC).
The group convicted in Serbia was not working only in France. According to the Serbian interior ministry, between April and September 2025 it threw green paint on the Holocaust museum, several synagogues and a restaurant in Paris, put up stickers, left the pig heads, and placed concrete “skeletons” bearing messages in front of the Brandenburg Gate in Berlin (N1, translated). The Serbian court concluded, OCCRP reports, that the goal was to “incite religious and national intolerance” and “destabilize the situation” in France and Germany (OCCRP).
Each border adds a cost that falls on the target country, not the sponsor: cross-border inquiries, requests for arrest and extradition, and trials that wait for defendants who may never be found. For the green paint attacks in Paris, French judges were by then able to use the new law. Suspects were placed under formal investigation in June 2025 for damage committed in connection with a foreign power (ICI).
Movement and the new lawPolitico Europe, October 29, 2025ICI, June 6, 2025BBC, September 11, 2025N1, September 29, 2025OCCRP, May 2026
Amplified online
The acts were designed to be seen, and the photographs travelled fast. In the stars of David case, France’s foreign ministry said its digital-interference agency, VIGINUM, had found “a network of 1,095 bots on the X platform” that published 2,589 posts, linked to the Russian network known as RRN or Doppelgänger. The bots began posting the photographs on October 28, 2023, “nearly 48 hours” before what appears to have been the first authentic publication (French foreign ministry, translated). In the red hands case, VIGINUM said accounts linked to Russia spread the story through “thousands of fake accounts on X” (BBC).
Russia denies involvement. In November 2023 its foreign ministry spokeswoman called the French accusations about the stars “stupid” (franceinfo). The Russian presidential administration and the Social Design Agency did not respond to OCCRP.
Online amplificationFrench foreign ministry, November 9, 2023franceinfo, November 15, 2023BBCVIGINUM, Storm-1516 analysis
The bill nobody added up
No French authority has published what these nine cases have cost. There is no figure for cleaning the memorial or the walls of two arrondissements, for protecting mosques and synagogues afterwards, for police and intelligence hours, for arrests and extraditions across Bulgaria and Croatia, or for a three-day trial. None of the reports on the Paris verdict mentions damages awarded to the civil parties. The Mémorial de la Shoah’s own annual report for 2024 records only that red hands “soiled the Memorial, which filed a complaint.”
France also publishes no consolidated record of physical acts attributed to foreign interference. What is public comes in pieces: foreign ministry statements, VIGINUM’s technical reports on online operations such as Storm-1516, and the count of nine cases the prosecutor’s office has given to journalists.
The logic of the method is not hidden. The foreign minister in May 2024, Stéphane Séjourné, described “sponsors paid to destabilize and press on the divisions of French society” (France 3, translated). Andrei Soldatov, a specialist on the Russian security services, told Forum 18 that such attacks are “not very costly to organise (and they don’t need to be successful),” and that their purpose is “to raise the costs of providing security for the European security agencies.” That is an expert’s assessment, not a finding. But the numbers that are public point the same way: a few thousand euros in fees on one side, and on the other a state response that nobody has priced.
CostsMémorial de la Shoah, annual report 2024France 3, June 3, 2024Forum 18, April 27, 2026VIGINUM, Storm-1516
What is established, and what is not
Established
- A Paris court convicted four Bulgarians over the red hands and found the acts were “committed from abroad with a hostile aim.” Court record
- Operatives were paid between 120 and 1,500 euros per job, according to court testimony, a police source and Serbian verdicts.
- France’s DGSI assessed that the red hands could correspond to an operation “orchestrated by the Russian intelligence services.”
- Serbian verdicts say the pig heads group was directed by Russian intelligence structures, as reported by Forum 18 and OCCRP. Court record
Not established
- Whether a French court will find Russian state direction in any of the nine cases.
- The exact Serbian sentences: house arrest (La Croix) or, for one man, prison (Forum 18).
- Who sits in the chain of intermediaries above the recruiters.
- The outcome of the other eight French cases, including the coffins and the green paint.
- What any of the cases cost in policing, protection, cleanup and prosecution.
Sources
- The red hands
- Payments
- The Paris trial
- The mosques
- Movement and the new law
- Online amplification
- Costs
For journalists and researchers
Key facts, citable
- About 500 red hands were painted in the 4th and 5th arrondissements of Paris in May 2024, 35 of them on the Mémorial de la Shoah. Source
- The Paris criminal court sentenced four Bulgarians to two to four years in prison on October 31, 2025. Source
- The driver in the Eiffel Tower coffins case said he was paid 120 euros, and the young men 400 euros. Source
- VIGINUM found a network of 1,095 bots on X that published 2,589 posts about the stars of David tags. Source
- Serbian verdicts say the pig heads group was directed by “structures of the intelligence service of the Russian Federation.” Source
Primary documents
- French foreign ministry statement, November 9, 2023
- Law on preventing foreign interference, July 2024 (Vie publique)
- VIGINUM, Storm-1516 analysis
- Serbian interior ministry statement (N1)
- OCCRP, leaked SDA documents
Cite this
Researchez. “Paid by the Job: The Hired Provocations in Paris, and the Bill Nobody Has Added Up.” Researchez, November 20, 2026. https://www.middleeastinfo.org/article-france-paid-provocations.
Researchez. (2026, November 20). Paid by the Job: The Hired Provocations in Paris, and the Bill Nobody Has Added Up. Researchez. https://www.middleeastinfo.org/article-france-paid-provocations
https://www.middleeastinfo.org/article-france-paid-provocations
Reuse
This report may be republished in full and without changes under CC BY-ND 4.0, with the credit line on Republish our work. Translations, edits and exclusive or paid use are by agreement: contact@www.middleeastinfo.org.
Updates and corrections
Changes to this report are noted at the end of the article with their date, and listed on Corrections.