Editorial illustration.
Editorial illustration.
In Depth · United States · Harvard, Penn, MIT, Columbia, Northwestern, Rutgers, UCLA

Seven Presidents, Three Hearings: What the Transcripts Say and What Happened Next

The House Education Committee’s antisemitism hearings of December 2023, April 2024 and May 2024 are remembered by a handful of clips. The official transcripts are longer and more ambiguous. Four of the seven university heads who testified were gone within two years.

Summary

  • Seven university leaders testified at three House Committee on Education and the Workforce hearings between December 5, 2023 and May 23, 2024. The committee’s own summary of the last one: “Three hearings and seven presidents later.”
  • The December 5, 2023 exchange that ended two presidencies runs over two pages of transcript. Penn’s Liz Magill said, “It is a context-dependent decision, Congresswoman”; Harvard’s Claudine Gay said, “It can be, depending on the context,” but had earlier said, “Calling for the genocide of Jews is antisemitic.”
  • Magill resigned on December 9, 2023 and stayed on as tenured faculty. Gay resigned on January 2, 2024. Columbia’s Minouche Shafik left effective August 14, 2024. Northwestern’s Michael Schill announced his resignation on September 4, 2025.
  • UCLA’s Gene Block told the committee he had already announced his retirement. MIT’s Sally Kornbluth remained in office. This review did not establish Rutgers president Jonathan Holloway’s later status.
  • Counts of discipline were contested at each hearing. The figures given under oath are worth quoting exactly, because later reporting often rounded or merged them.

December 5, 2023: “context-dependent”

The first hearing, “Holding Campus Leaders Accountable and Confronting Antisemitism,” brought Gay, Magill and Kornbluth before the committee alongside Pamela Nadell, a historian at American University. The exchange that drew attention came late in the session, when Representative Elise Stefanik asked each president whether calling for the genocide of Jews would breach their institution’s rules.

Kornbluth answered that such speech “would be investigated as harassment if pervasive and severe.” Then the transcript records:

Ms. Stefanik. Ms. Magill, at Penn, does calling for the genocide of Jews violate Penn’s rules or code of conduct, yes, or no?

Ms. Magill. If the speech turns into conduct, it can be harassment, yes.

Ms. Stefanik. I am asking specifically calling for the genocide of Jews, does that constitute bullying or harassment?

Ms. Magill. If it is directed and severe or pervasive, it is harassment.

Ms. Stefanik. So the answer is yes?

Ms. Magill. It is a context-dependent decision, Congresswoman.

When Stefanik turned to Gay, the answer was “It can be, depending on the context,” and, after a follow-up, “Again, it depends on the context.” Stefanik replied: “It does not depend on the context. The answer is yes, and this is why you should resign.”

The clips usually omit an earlier exchange in the same hearing. Asked a similar question by Stefanik, Gay began with Harvard’s harassment rules and then said: “Calling for the genocide of Jews is antisemitic.” When Stefanik asked “So yes?”, Gay said, “And that is antisemitic speech,” and began to explain the line between speech and conduct.

The resignations

Four days later, on December 9, 2023, Penn’s board chair, Scott L. Bok, announced that Magill had “voluntarily tendered her resignation.” The notice in the Penn Almanac added: “She will remain a tenured faculty member at Penn Carey Law.” An interim president was named on December 12.

Gay resigned on January 2, 2024. The Harvard Corporation’s statement said it accepted the resignation “with sorrow.” It acknowledged that Gay “has acknowledged missteps and has taken responsibility for them” and condemned “repugnant and in some cases racist vitriol directed at her.” Provost Alan M. Garber became interim president.

April 17, 2024: counting suspensions

Columbia’s hearing brought Shafik, board co-chairs Claire Shipman and David Greenwald, and David Schizer, co-chair of Columbia’s antisemitism task force and a former law dean. Shipman’s account of discipline: “We’ve suspended two student groups for noncompliance, more than a dozen individual students, and we disciplined faculty members.” Pressed by chair Virginia Foxx, Shafik gave a higher figure: “we have already suspended 15 students from Columbia. We have six on disciplinary probation. These are more disciplinary actions that have been taken, than probably in the last decade in Columbia.”

A committee member, citing documents Columbia had produced, put a different number on the record: the university had “only suspended three students for antisemitic incidents between October 7th and March 24th,” and those had been “lifted or reduced.” The two figures measure different things, all suspensions versus those coded as antisemitic incidents, and should not be compared without that caveat.

Shafik announced her departure in August, effective August 14, 2024. “This period has taken a considerable toll on my family, as it has for others in our community,” she wrote.

May 23, 2024: negotiated endings on trial

The third hearing called the leaders of three universities that had handled encampments differently. Northwestern and Rutgers had negotiated; UCLA’s camp had been attacked and then cleared. Block opened by noting: “Last summer I announced my intent to retire this July, after leading UCLA for 17” years.

The committee’s recap reported the discipline answers this way: “President Holloway mustered the only real number among all three university heads for both questions, testifying that only four students were suspended.” Schill, it said, “admitted that Northwestern had failed to suspend or expel a single student for antisemitic conduct since October 7.” Foxx closed: “Today’s hearing is the beginning, not the end of Committee’s investigation of your institutions.”

Holloway defended the Rutgers deal in terms that described the choice every campus faced: “We made a choice. That choice was to engage our students through dialogue, as a first option, instead of police action.”

Schill announced his resignation on September 4, 2025, five months into a federal funding freeze.

Reading the record

The hearings were political events. They were also sworn testimony, and the transcripts remain the best primary record of what institutions said they were doing in real time. The suspension counts, in particular, can now be checked against later documents: Columbia’s 2026 compliance report, Northwestern’s 2025 resolution agreement, and court filings.

LeaderInstitutionHearingOutcome
Claudine GayHarvardDec 5, 2023Resigned Jan 2, 2024
Liz MagillPennDec 5, 2023Resignation announced Dec 9, 2023; remains faculty
Sally KornbluthMITDec 5, 2023Remained in office
Minouche ShafikColumbiaApr 17, 2024Stepped down effective Aug 14, 2024
Michael SchillNorthwesternMay 23, 2024Resignation announced Sept 4, 2025
Gene BlockUCLAMay 23, 2024Retirement announced before the hearing
Jonathan HollowayRutgersMay 23, 2024Not established in this review

Sources

  1. US House Committee on Education and the Workforce, transcript, December 5, 2023
  2. Same committee, “Columbia in Crisis” transcript, April 17, 2024
  3. Same committee, transcript, May 23, 2024
  4. Same committee, hearing recap, May 2024
  5. University of Pennsylvania Almanac, “A Message to the Penn Community: Resignation of President Liz Magill,” December 9, 2023
  6. Harvard Corporation, “Statement from the Harvard Corporation: President Gay,” January 2, 2024
  7. Teachers College, Columbia University, “Columbia University Leadership Change,” August 2024
  8. Northwestern University, “President Michael Schill Announces Resignation,” September 4, 2025

Further reading

Topics: legal outcome.