Editorial illustration.
Editorial illustration.
In Depth · United States · Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts

Harvard Refused Washington’s Demands. Columbia Settled and Reports Meeting Many of Them.

The April 11, 2025 federal letter to Harvard listed changes to discipline, masks, student groups and academic programs. Harvard said no and went to court. Columbia, which settled, now reports compliance with many of the same items. Side by side, the two records show what was traded.

Summary

  • The April 11, 2025 letter demanded, among other things, “a comprehensive mask ban with serious and immediate penalties for violation, not less than suspension,” a single disciplinary body “accountable to Harvard’s president,” derecognition of five named pro-Palestinian groups, and external audits of 10 named schools, centers and programs.
  • Harvard’s president, Alan Garber, replied on April 14: “The University will not surrender its independence or relinquish its constitutional rights.” Freezes and grant terminations followed; Reuters put the total at about $2.2 billion.
  • Judge Allison Burroughs ruled for Harvard on September 3, 2025. A final judgment of October 20, 2025, in the companion case brought by Harvard faculty groups, declared the freeze orders violated the First Amendment and the termination letters violated Title VI’s procedures, and vacated them.
  • The government appealed. At the First Circuit on October 5, 2026, its lawyer argued “there’s no First Amendment right to money.” Judge Sandra Lynch replied that “there are no findings. There was no investigation.” No decision had been published as of November 18, 2026.
  • Harvard’s own antisemitism task force, reporting April 29, 2025, found that 39% of Jewish student respondents did not feel at home at Harvard and 26% felt physically unsafe. The parallel survey showed Muslim respondents reporting the most negative outcomes of any group.

The letter

The letter sent to Garber and Penny Pritzker, senior fellow of the Harvard Corporation, on April 11, 2025, set most of its deadlines for August 2025. Some of its demands concerned admissions and hiring. Others bore directly on protest:

  • “a disciplinary process housed in one body that is accountable to Harvard’s president or other capstone official,” and the removal or reform of “the relevant Administrative Boards and FAS Faculty Council”;
  • “a comprehensive mask ban with serious and immediate penalties for violation, not less than suspension”;
  • an end to recognition of “the Harvard Palestine Solidarity Committee, Harvard Graduates Students 4 Palestine, Law Students 4 Palestine, Students for Justice in Palestine, and the National Lawyers Guild,” and discipline of their officers and active members;
  • discipline for “the spring encampment of 2024” and earlier incidents;
  • an external audit of “programs and departments that most fuel antisemitic harassment or reflect ideological capture,” naming among others the Divinity School, the Center for Middle Eastern Studies and the Department of Near Eastern Languages and Cultures;
  • a departmental “viewpoint diversity” audit, repeated each year “at least until the end of 2028.”

Harvard’s lawyers responded on April 14 that the university “is committed to fighting antisemitism,” but would not accept the terms. Garber’s message to the community the same day contained the sentence that framed the next 18 months: “The University will not surrender its independence or relinquish its constitutional rights.”

The court record

The government’s response came in stages. The October 2025 final judgment lists the instruments: an April 14 freeze order, a May 5 freeze order, and termination letters from the NIH, the Departments of Agriculture, Commerce, Defense, Energy, Housing and Urban Development and Education, NASA, the NSF, the CDC and the General Services Administration, dated from May 6 to May 27, 2025.

Burroughs’s September 3 memorandum, issued in Harvard’s suit and a companion case brought by faculty groups, found for the plaintiffs. The final judgment in the faculty case, entered October 20, 2025, incorporates that ruling and is short and categorical. The freeze orders are “DECLARED to violate the First Amendment.” The termination letters are “DECLARED to violate Title VI of the Civil Rights Act,” because the statute’s procedures for cutting off funds were not followed. “All freezes and terminations of funding to Harvard made pursuant to the Freeze Orders and Termination Letters on or after April 14, 2025 are VACATED AND SET ASIDE,” the order says, and the government is permanently enjoined from giving them effect.

On appeal, according to The Harvard Crimson, the government argued that the district court had no power to order the restoration of “nearly $2.7 billion in research grants” because grant disputes belong in the Court of Federal Claims. “When you look specifically at the grant terminations, there’s no First Amendment right to money,” Justice Department lawyer Michael Velchik told the panel. Paul Clement, for Harvard, said: “They are claims to be free from retaliatory discrimination under the First Amendment.” Judge Lynch questioned why Title VI’s process had been skipped: “The claim is that Harvard has been indifferent to antisemitism, and there are no findings. There was no investigation.”

The comparison

Columbia did not litigate. Its October 2026 compliance report, filed under the July 2025 resolution agreement, lets a reader check how far its campus now resembles what Harvard was asked to become.

April 2025 demand to HarvardColumbia’s reported position, October 2026
One disciplinary body accountable to the president or another top officialUniversity Judicial Board “now housed in and administered by the Office of the Provost”; panels “comprised solely of faculty and administrative staff”; final appeals to the president
Comprehensive mask banPolicies on “masking and required identification expectations, including disciplinary repercussions for noncompliance”
Review of Middle East programsSenior vice provost review “starting with the Middle East,” covering the Center for Palestine Studies and the Institute for Israel and Jewish Studies, still “In Progress”
Discipline for protest disruptionProtest “inside academic buildings” is “not acceptable”; no 2025–26 demonstrations led to rules charges

The comparison has limits. Columbia’s agreement was negotiated, and its text states that it gives the government no authority to dictate hiring, admissions or academic speech. Harvard’s letter was a set of unilateral demands, and parts of it, such as derecognizing named groups or the departmental viewpoint audits, have no direct counterpart in Columbia’s report.

What Harvard found on its own

Harvard’s case is not that it had no problem. Its Presidential Task Force on Combating Antisemitism and Anti-Israeli Bias published a final report on April 29, 2025, two weeks after the refusal. A joint survey with the parallel task force on anti-Muslim, anti-Arab and anti-Palestinian bias drew 2,295 responses between May and August 2024, with Jewish, Israeli, Muslim and Arab affiliates likely overrepresented. In all, 477 respondents identified as Jewish. Among Jewish students, the report says 39% did not feel at home at the university “at least to some extent,” 26% felt physically unsafe, 44% felt mentally unsafe and 49% felt unsupported.

The same data showed a sharper picture for Muslim respondents. “Across all measures of safety and belonging we see Muslim community members report the most negative outcomes followed by Jewish community members,” the survey analysis says; 47% of Muslim respondents and 15% of Jewish respondents across the community said they did not feel physically safe, against 6% of Christians and non-religious respondents. The task force wrote that it was not trying “to engage in a contest to prove which group has suffered more.”

Open questions

  • The First Circuit decision. If the government wins on jurisdiction, the money question moves to the Court of Federal Claims; the First Amendment finding could survive either way.
  • Whether Harvard adopted any of the letter’s disciplinary changes on its own initiative. Its task-force recommendations should be tracked item by item.

Sources

  1. US government letter to Harvard University, April 11, 2025
  2. Harvard counsel response, April 14, 2025
  3. Alan M. Garber, “The Promise of American Higher Education,” April 14, 2025
  4. US District Court for the District of Massachusetts, American Association of University Professors–Harvard Faculty Chapter et al. v. US Department of Justice et al., Order and Final Judgment, October 20, 2025 (Case 1:25-cv-10910-ADB, Doc. 153)
  5. Reuters, “Trump administration unlawfully cut Harvard’s funding, US judge rules,” September 3, 2025. (consulted via search summary; Reuters blocks automated access)
  6. The Harvard Crimson, “Trump Administration Asks First Circuit to Reinstate Harvard Funding Cuts,” October 6, 2026
  7. Harvard University, Presidential Task Force on Combating Antisemitism and Anti-Israeli Bias, Final Report, April 29, 2025
  8. Columbia University, Resolution Agreement Semi-Annual Report, October 2026

Further reading

Topics: legal outcome, research ties, cost.