New York’s $3 Billion Asylum Bill and the Federal Budget
The city’s expense ledger and the federal immigration forecast measure different fiscal outcomes.
In 60 seconds
New York City recorded $3.020 billion in spending on services for asylum seekers in fiscal 2025, down from $3.752 billion the year before. The city’s own funds covered $1.477 billion, about $174 for each New Yorker; the state was assigned $1.455 billion and the federal government $88 million. The figures may still be revised. A federal forecast that immigration reduces deficits measures something else, and does not pay the city’s bills.
Key points
- New York City recorded $3.020 billion in asylum-seeker services in fiscal 2025, down from $3.752 billion in fiscal 2024 and up from $1.474 billion in fiscal 2023. The comptroller says the figures may be revised.
- For fiscal 2025, the city assigned $1.477 billion to city funds, $1.455 billion to the state and $88 million to federal funding. An assignment is not cash collected.
- The Congressional Budget Office’s 2024 projection of a net $0.9 trillion federal deficit reduction over 2024–2034 compares economic scenarios; it does not measure or reimburse city shelter bills.

New York City recorded $3.020 billion in asylum-seeker services in fiscal 2025, down from $3.752 billion in fiscal 2024 and above $1.474 billion in fiscal 2023. These are accrued expenses in the city’s financial system, including funding assigned to city, state and federal sources. The comptroller cautions that the figures may be revised.
Who was expected to pay?
The fiscal 2025 table assigns $1.477 billion to city funds, $1.455 billion to the state and $88 million to federal funding. A funding assignment is distinct from cash already collected. The comptroller separately tracks state reimbursement claims and federal funding risks. For the cost of the service itself, use the total. For local budget exposure, track actual reimbursements as well as gross spending.
NYC Comptroller fiscal tables and funding notes
Why CBO reaches a different conclusion
In its 2024 analysis, the Congressional Budget Office projected that the immigration surge would reduce federal deficits by a net $0.9 trillion over 2024–2034 through its effects on revenue, mandatory spending and interest. That estimate compares two economic scenarios. It does not measure actual shelter bills or reimburse New York for them. Higher local costs and higher federal tax receipts can occur at the same time.