Editorial illustration.
Editorial illustration.
Germany Desk · Berlin · Immigration law

Berlin Moved to Remove Four Gaza Protesters. All Four Won the First Round in Court.

In March 2025 Berlin’s immigration office acted against three EU citizens and one American over protest activity. The administrative court suspended the measures, and a first main ruling in 2026 found one of them unlawful.

Summary

  • In March 2025 Berlin’s immigration office (LEA) found that three EU citizens, two Irish and one Polish according to beck-aktuell, had lost their right of free movement, and expelled a US citizen.
  • All four challenged the measures in urgent proceedings and won, LTO reported. Three of the orders are documented: April 10, 2025 (24 L 91/25) and May 6, 2025 (21 L 157/25 and 29 L 314/25).
  • The courts said suspicion and assumptions were not enough, and in one case that the office had not obtained the prosecutor’s files.
  • On May 6, 2026, the court ruled in the first main case that the withdrawal of an Irish woman’s free-movement right was unlawful. That judgment is not yet final.

What the immigration office did

In March 2025, Berlin’s State Office for Immigration took two kinds of measure. For three EU citizens it formally found the loss of their right of free movement under the EU Free Movement Act, which exposes a person to deportation. For one American it ordered expulsion under the Residence Act. According to LTO, the US citizen was “aus der Bundesrepublik Deutschland ausgewiesen”. beck-aktuell reported that the EU citizens were an Irish man, an Irish woman and a Polish woman. The four are private individuals and are not named in the court decisions; this report does not name them.

Three orders, one finding

On April 10, 2025, the 24th chamber of the Berlin administrative court granted the Irish man’s urgent application (24 L 91/25). According to beck-aktuell, the court found that the office had not met its duty to investigate the facts and had not requested the prosecutor’s files. The report added that Berlin’s interior administration said it would not appeal that order.

On May 6, 2025, two more chambers ruled. The 21st chamber found “durchgreifende Bedenken gegen die materielle Rechtmäßigkeit” (serious doubts about the substantive lawfulness) of the measure against the Irish woman (21 L 157/25), LTO reported. The 29th chamber restored suspensive effect against the American’s expulsion (29 L 314/25). Its order states: “Mutmaßungen oder ein bloßer Verdacht genügen insoweit nicht” (conjecture or mere suspicion is not enough). The order also records that the applicant holds Canadian as well as US citizenship.

No court record was found for the Polish woman’s case. Her success rests on LTO’s statement that “alle vier Gaza-Aktivisten” (all four Gaza activists) won in urgent proceedings.

The first main ruling

On May 6, 2026, a year after the urgent orders, the court decided the Irish woman’s main case and found the withdrawal of her free-movement right unlawful, according to the court’s press release and LTO. The judgment can still be challenged by an application for leave to appeal to the Higher Administrative Court of Berlin-Brandenburg. LTO reported that the main cases of the other three were still pending.

What the courts have not decided

The urgent orders did not settle the lawfulness of the measures; that is for the main proceedings. They did not decide whether the four took part in the occupation at the Free University on October 17, 2024 that the office had cited, or the outcome of any criminal investigation. The 29th chamber also left open whether the formal requirements for immediate enforcement had been met.

Sources

  1. Verwaltungsgericht Berlin, order of May 6, 2025, 29 L 314/25 (full text)
  2. beck-aktuell on order 24 L 91/25, April 11, 2025
  3. Legal Tribune Online on order 21 L 157/25, May 2025
  4. Legal Tribune Online on the immigration office’s notices, April 4, 2025
  5. Verwaltungsgericht Berlin, press release 24/2026 on the main judgment
  6. Legal Tribune Online on the main judgment, May 6, 2026

Every fact in this report is taken from the documents listed above. Updated November 19, 2026.