Editorial illustration.
Editorial illustration.
Germany Desk · Munich · Courts

Munich Tried to Move a Protest Camp. Two Courts Said the City Had Not Shown a Danger.

In May 2024 the city relocated a pro-Palestinian camp, capped it at five tents and banned sleeping there. Within two days, both courts that looked at the order suspended the key parts of it.

Summary

  • On May 13, 2024, the city of Munich moved a pro-Palestinian protest camp to another site, limited it to five tents and prohibited sleeping in them.
  • The same day, the Munich administrative court suspended the relocation and the tent rules (order M 10 S 24.2384). It found the city’s danger forecast insufficient.
  • On May 14, 2024, the Bavarian Administrative Court dismissed the city’s appeal (order 10 CS 24.798). Suspicion and assumptions, it said, are not enough to restrict an assembly. According to LTO, that order cannot be appealed.
  • Both rulings were urgent, summary reviews. Neither decided the main case, the content of the protest, or how many tents would be acceptable.

What the city ordered

The city’s notice of May 13, 2024 did two things. It moved the assembly away from its registered location, and it limited the camp’s tents to five while prohibiting overnight stays. In the words of the administrative court, the city had “die angezeigten Zelte auf fünf beschränkt und das Nächtigen bzw. Schlafen untersagt” (limited the registered tents to five and prohibited spending the night or sleeping). The legal news service LTO reported that the alternative site was about one kilometre away; that distance does not appear in the court’s text.

The first ruling: the forecast was not enough

The 10th chamber of the Munich administrative court ruled on the organisers’ urgent application the same day. It ordered suspensive effect for the relocation (item 3 of the notice) and for the tent rules (item 4.2.4). On the tents, the court wrote that the city’s danger forecast “ist insoweit nicht ausreichend” (is not sufficient in this respect). On the relocation, it found that the risk the city cited, that lecture halls could be occupied, was “nicht hinreichend konkret nachgewiesen” (not shown concretely enough).

The appeal: suspicion is not a reason

The city appealed. On May 14, 2024, the 10th senate of the Bavarian Administrative Court dismissed the appeal and ordered the city to pay the costs. It restated the standard for restricting an assembly: a danger forecast must rest on “konkrete und nachvollziehbare tatsächliche Anhaltspunkte” (concrete and verifiable facts), and “bloße Verdachtsmomente und Vermutungen reichen für sich allein nicht aus” (mere suspicion and assumptions are not enough on their own).

On the tents, the court said the number of tents belongs to the organisers’ right to decide how to hold their assembly, and that it remained unclear “welche konkrete Gefahr vom Übernachten in den Zelten ausgehen sollte” (what concrete danger staying overnight in the tents was supposed to pose). LTO reported that the order cannot be appealed.

What the courts did not decide

Both rulings were summary reviews in urgent proceedings. They suspended parts of the city’s order; they did not annul it, and they did not decide the main action. The appeal court expressly left open whether the event was a standing vigil or a protest camp. Neither court ruled on the content of the protest, on a permissible number of tents, or on whether disruption would occur. They found only that the city had not backed its forecast with concrete facts.

The Munich case is a counterpoint to Berlin, where the police dissolution of the Palestine Congress in April 2024 was later ruled unlawful in a full judgment. [Read that report](article-berlin-shut-down-palestine-congress-after.html).

Sources

  1. Verwaltungsgericht München, order of May 13, 2024, M 10 S 24.2384 (full text)
  2. Bayerischer Verwaltungsgerichtshof, order of May 14, 2024, 10 CS 24.798 (full text)
  3. Legal Tribune Online on the appeal court’s order

Every fact in this report is taken from the documents listed above. Updated November 19, 2026.