Start here

How we decide who is behind an attack

Saying who did something is the hardest part of reporting on sabotage and cyberattacks. We never decide it ourselves. We report who said it, on what evidence, and label it.

The five labels

Government-attributed
A state or an official agency has publicly named the actor. Example: France named the unit it blames for the refrigeration attacks, in The Blockade Inside.
Court record
A court ruling or an official legal document establishes it. Example: the Berlin courts’ rulings on the Palestine Congress, in this In Depth report.
Vendor assessment
A private security company has made the finding and no government has adopted it. Example: Cyabra’s attribution of a fake-account network, in When Propaganda Goes Offline.
Claim only
Someone says they did it, and nothing independent confirms it. Example: the claim for the November 2026 attacks on European stores.
Officially ruled out
The authorities examined an explanation and rejected it, for example a cyberattack ruled out as the cause of an outage.

Four questions we always answer

  1. Who made the attribution?
  2. On what evidence?
  3. Who denied it?
  4. What did independent researchers find?

Every investigation ends with a box, What is established, and what is not, that separates the two. Full rules: Methods.